4 ms·
I would love the idea (for data-driven science) of a peer review before execution of the work. Write up a one- or 2-pager, review methodology and accept/reject
by Beldin 6y ago
I would love the idea (for data-driven science) of a peer review before execution of the work. Write up a one- or 2-pager, review methodology and accept/reject based on that.
Once the work has been done, there would mostly be editorial comments.
Of course, that ignores the analysis section, which is somewhat important.
But still, a vast improvement over today's way, where you may end up spending a lot of time only to get a vague reject.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThis is similar to “triple blind” but the reviewers review methodology before they have access to the results, but after the work has been performed.