3 ms·
I find it rather telling that almost none of the crypto advocates in this thread make any argument that cryptocurrencies are not shady. Instead, the counterargu
by xg15 6y ago
I find it rather telling that almost none of the crypto advocates in this thread make any argument that cryptocurrencies are not shady. Instead, the counterarguments brought forward are essentially:
- "it's not the tool's fault that it's used for shady stuff"
- "so what, other people are scammers, too!"
- "there are so many warnings against cryptocurrencies, it's getting boring"
- "yes, crypto has scams, but maybe some of them are good scams!"
- "the author is biased!"
- "the author should give more details!"
That's not exactly a confidence-inspiring picture of the crypto community.
- everfree 6y agoTo be fair, many of those counterarguments would be seen as valid if we were discussing, say, private messengers instead of cryptocurrency: * It's not Signal Messenger's fault that it's used for shady stuff. * There are so many warnings against unbreakable strong encryption, it's getting boring. * Many people are biased against strong encryption In the end, like private messaging, cryptocurrency is just a tool that can be used for good or evil. I don't think that the general concept needs to be "defended as not being shady" any more than any other technology that enables scams, e.g. phones, youtube[1], the internet. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/23/21335554/steve-wozniak-youtube-lawsuit-bitcoin-scam-cryptocurrency-apple https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/23/21335554/steve-wozniak-yo...
- olodus 6y agoI don't really understand what you think it is telling of. I am perfectly fine with expressing that I agree with the article - a lot of the crypto currencies out on the market today are very close to or actual scams. At the same time I very much think that the idea/technology of crypto currencies has potential. I also think that language like Haskell, that prides itself in correctness and bug-free code, fits perfectly with developing that idea. I would say that is one of the large problems even more established cryptos has - they might have a bug. I neither really see the reason why the Haskell community should be scared of having crypto people among them. What is the worst thing they could really do with the language? Fill up youtube with a lot of haskell+crypto speeches? Add crypto - related lib and code to the language? Is that really a bad thing?
- Vosporos 6y agoVery fair assessment of the situation.
- dpc_pw 6y ago"Crypto community" is not a unified group of people, holding hands and singing "kumbaya", you know? Quite the opposite - fights and accusing almost all competing projects of technical and/or moral failures are a bread and butter of crypto. It's safe to say that most people in crypto space admits that the space is somewhat shady. How else could it be? Money are involved so it attracts people trying to exploit it and brings the worst side of many, otherwise decent participants, and anyone can create yet another crypto project and there's nothing to stop them. And it's always "your word and opinion against mine" kind of thing. BTW. It's funny how many people on HN, have no problem with "regular" SV companies often based on: praying on dark marketing patterns, human dopamine addiction, data collection, overly optimistic return projections and so many other "sins", but are quick to discredit "crypto" as a whole, to the point where they would ban it from using their favorite programming languages. :D
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tdeck 6y agoI didn't see anyone discussions banning crypto users from Haskell - it's certainly not in the original article. The point was about which actors have the most influence on the community. Apparently the author is also very concerned about companies like Facebook which you might call more respectable.
- centimeter 6y agoYou should have zero confidence in "the crypto community". On expectation, anyone who describes themselves in those terms is probably a scammer. Bitcoin is not a scam, and maybe a small number of other "cryptocurrencies", but the same can not be said for any of the zillion products that try to ride on Bitcoin's coattails.
- 127 6y agoIt's impossible to build a money system that isn't at some level shady, outside making it completely totalitarian. Just based on simple definitions and some logic.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]