6 ms·
I think this is a rather strange way of thinking. Fortran has been extensively used for nuclear weapons development. Let's stay away from Fortran! C was and i
by nine_k 6y ago
I think this is a rather strange way of thinking.
Fortran has been extensively used for nuclear weapons development. Let's stay away from Fortran!
C was and is widely used in weapons control systems. Let's stop using C!
Computers themselves were initially designed for artillery fire control, with an explicit intention of killing people. Let's not touch the technology with such a foul pedigree.
This can be continued ad nauseam, until the whole of the civilization is marked as indecent. Nearly every scientific discovery and techology achievement has been used, or attempted to be used, for some purpose one might find objectionable.
Instead we could realize that tools are outside morals. A knife could be used to cut bread or to cut throats, and it's not the knife's decision, but that of its user. The very same thing applies to everything, from nuclear fission to functional programming.
If you know what's the right, virtuous thing to do in the world, do not hesitate, go and do it. Use the most fitting tool for that job. Do not mind if that tool is used for whatever other, less noble purpose, it's not the tool's fault.
- ajuc 6y agoIBM helped with Holocaust. It also invented PC.
- frank2 6y agoIf you're trying to say that IBM invented the home computer or the personal computer, you are off by about 6 years. (Home computers became available around 1975; home computers that didn't not need any assembly by the buyer became available in 1976 or 1977; the IBM PC became available in 1981.) If you're trying to say that IBM was the first to officially name a personal computer "PC", I'll give you that one.
- nine_k 6y agoIt did create a personal computer which was (1) easy to clone and (2) easy to extend with ISA cards. This openness made it a huge success, leading to an explosion of PC-compatible machines. Most other makers, from Apple to Amiga, vigorously protected their small private markets where they dominated. The original Macintosh has explicitly removed all the expansion capabilities that e.g. Apple II had.
- frank2 6y agoIt accidentally made it easy to clone by rushing to market, making false assumptions and hoping the enterprise market would soon lose interest in personal computers. Rushing to market led to the decision to license the OS from Bill Gates instead of buying the OS or writing it in-house. An example of a false assumption would be believing that holding the copyright on the BIOS would be enough prevent clones.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoS-100 was open.
- nine_k 6y agoYes, and extermely widely used, despite its bitter flaws.
- nine_k 6y agoWerner von Braun bombed London with V-2s during WWII and was a Nazi party member above the rank-and-file level. Werner von Braun has lead the US space program to launching humans to LEO, and then to the Moon. Again, technology is morally oblivious. A sword that only serves a noble aim is strictly the stuff of fairy tales, and is not implementable in the real world (no, not even with an AGI, since humans are a reasonably good approximation of an AGI).
- fwip 6y agoTechnology is not inherently morally oblivious. Some technology has only one purpose, and is used only for immoral acts. An example of this would be any device invented for torture. While those examples are uncommon, more technology is built expressly for evil acts, even if it has the capacity for good. If you are distributing plans and technology to make "dirty bombs" - devices intended to disperse lethal amounts of radiation - it's impossible for a reasonable person to believe that it is not intended to murder people via radiation. Furthermore, in the context of today's world, you know that the most likely users of such a device would be terrorist organizations who will target innocent civilians. An even greater percentage of technology is developed to support people doing evil acts. If you provide software or hardware to people doing evil acts (in this case, the Holocaust), you are giving them material aid. The software written to tabulate Jewish residents in Germany was developed for the Nazi party. Technical support and sales continued well after Nazi Germany had invaded Poland. The fact that a man (or company) enriched himself by doing both bad and good things does not mean that his actions were morally neutral. Most people alive have done both bad and good things.
- nine_k 6y agoThe same firearm can be user to assault an innocent person and to protect an innocent person (in the hands of said person or law enforcement / army). There are certain devices, like napalm bombs, that have a narrow and specific purpose of destruction. But the technologies used to make the bomb shells or the napalm are not specific, and have all kinds of peaceful and constructive uses. Equally, there can be bad, evil-pursuing programs in a particular general purpose language, but this does not taint that language.
- lsllc 6y agoI would go as far as to say IBM was "complicit": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust#Summary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust#Summary
- kabdib 6y ago> It also invented PC. No. Personal computers were around for quite a while before IBM decided to enter the market (with a not very good and very expensive machine, I should add). The PC mantle probably goes to Processor Technology, or maybe someone a little earlier. I'm counting 8-bit chipsets, the date gets pushed back a LOT farther if you're talking PDP-8s or earlier systems (much less commonly available to the public). Or you could take it forward to 1977/78 and give the title to Apple. But it's definitely not IBM.
- umvi 6y agoDoesn't stop people from trying to have the cake and eat it too. I think I remember reading about a FOSS project on GitHub that put a clause in the license that said something along the lines of "this software is free to use except for purposes we deem immoral in which case you can't use it" (sorry, I can't remember which project it was)
- nine_k 6y agoYes, there's a nice funny joke of this nature in the JSON license: "The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil." [1] I remember IBM had to obtain a separate license without this clause, to insure themselves against potential nice funny lawsuits claiming the breach of that clause. [1]: http://www.json.org/license.html http://www.json.org/license.html
- nonbirithm 6y agoWas it Learna? https://github.com/lerna/lerna/pull/1616 https://github.com/lerna/lerna/pull/1616 https://github.com/jamiebuilds/license https://github.com/jamiebuilds/license Its proposed license was an extension to MIT which made using it theft for a select list of companies that supported ICE.
- burkaman 6y agoI realize the article is very vaguely written, but I don't think the argument is "Haskell has been used for cryptocurrency and that taints it forever." I read it as "A significant portion of jobs and funding in the Haskell ecosystem come from cryptocurrency organizations, giving them a lot of influence over the future of the language and the community." It's about who controls development of the tool right now, not how the tool might be used, or who has been involved in the past.
- nine_k 6y agoCan mathematics be developed for nefarious purposes? What kind of taint the current influence of the crypto-currency industry could leave on the technical side of the language? If these guys are toxic within the development community, then, well, we have to somehow handle it — but again, we've seen highly prolific and highly toxic OSS contributors who wielded very different, "more noble" values, in the past. The problem may be the attitude, not the industry affiliation.
- mnsc 6y agoInteresting that you brought up mathematics. My shallow view of the haskell community is that they think haskell is/should be as theoretically solid as mathematics. And based on this, my interpretation of the underlying fear in the article is analogous to the Russian government somehow duping all the world's mathematicians to only work on the problem domain of breaking cryptos (and incidentally primarily the type of cryptos used by "enemy" nations) and all the mathematicians dropping everything and going "yeah, that sound super cool let's do that, maybe someone else will pick up my work in combinatorial topography"
- tome 6y agoWhy the Russian government specifically? Plenty of nations do encourage this of (some of) their mathematicians and this practice is also poorly regarded by some.
- 6y ago
- Thomashuet 6y agoI think you're misunderstanding the author here. He doesn't argue that people shouldn't use Haskell because it's used in crypto currencies, quite the opposite he seems to love Haskell and want people to use it. His worry is that being associated with crooks will make the Haskell community less attractive.
- nine_k 6y agoMy point is exactly that: a technology itself can't be tainted by crooks using it. Have innumerable script kiddies, scammers, doorway site creators, etc, used PHP for doing bad things? Did / do they constitute a significant part of the user community? Yes. Has PHP been used to create wonderful and world-changing things, like Wikipedia? Does PHP have great, very nicely designed tools that help people develop good things faster, like Laravel? Has the PHP community done a tremendous work to make the language much better, and its stdlib much nicer? Yes. Crooks using your favorite tool can be a nuisance in the community, but noble-intentioned people can be jerks, too, which has many times been observed. If the community has a problem with its being nice, welcoming, constructive place, it's usually not because of people's business and even political affiliation. I'll hazard to link to [1] as a supplementary reading on the topic. [1]: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/GLMFmFvXGyAcG25ni/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/GLMFmFvXGyAcG25ni/i-can-tole... (It's a copy; unfortunately the author has taken his whole huge blog offline.)
- rkangel 6y agoQuality of a language's community does affect the experience of using it. PHP is great example to use though - just because people are doing nefarious things doesn't make them unpleasant people. The difference between this and the PHP case is one of economics. Economic input gives you influence (usually). If people who's approach to life you don't agree with assume influence over the direction of a project, that can be a source of worry. I'm not sure I think it would be in this case, I think a source of finance is probably going to outweigh it, but I see the logic.
- syrrim 6y ago>the author has taken his whole huge blog offline Look again
- xg15 6y agoNope. This is a call to the Haskell developer community to stop cooperation with crypto projects, not a general call to stop using Haskell. I.e., it's a call to the knife makers to stop making their knifes to the specs of mob bosses, not a call to ban knifes. There are plenty of precedents for this kind of action, e.g. pharmaceutical companies refusing to supply chemicals for executions. (If were already going all life-and-death with the analogies)
- nine_k 6y agoThis sounds quite reasonable! But if all a knife needs is a sharp blade, there's little to be done in the way of limiting its specific uses. Also, do cryptocurrency bosses ask the community to shape Haskell in the way suitable for them, e.g. in the core libraries or extensions? Or do they just produce libraries for their own use?
- vincnetas 6y agoIts more like, would you enjoy your weekend foodball game if you knew that stadium was build by slaves. Theres nothing bad in stadium it self, but the circumstances how it came to be are not acceptable for you.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> C was and is widely used in weapons control systems. Let's stop using C! Let's definitely stop using C in weapons control systems.
- shpongled 6y agoI consider Stephen to be an extremist when it comes to stuff like this. I follow him on twitter, and he frequently tweets things like: "More programmers should have the moral fortitude to stand up to the Facebook employees in their communities. This is not a socially acceptable career. Facebook employees have chosen to turn their skills on poisoning the very communities that gave them opportunities to thrive." [0] "Palantir and Facebook are the largest employers of Rust engineers in the world. Rust Community: What exactly is the point of all of your long codes of conduct and community guidelines if the primary use for your language is the creation of a nightmare surveillance state?" [1] [0]: https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1288532583530323970 https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1288532583530323970 [1]: https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1288106450707873794 https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1288106450707873794
- mcguire 6y agoWell, to be honest, the negative beliefs about Facebook and Palantir are pretty common; I suspect rather a lot of people here would agree that Facebook is "poisoning the very communities that gave them opportunities to thrive" and Palantir is creating "a nightmare surveillance state". If that is the case, it seems like Stephen would be just a little less hypocritical than most, trying to convince programmers to actually follow through. A short while back, I mentioned here that Henry Petroski said that the origin of engineering ethics is that engineers shouldn't compete solely on price. That hasn't been the case for a long time, not since some bridge fell down and killed a bunch of people. Now, engineering ethics involves saying "no" when you boss wants you to do something you feel is unethical, illegal, or just plain stupid. Nobody wants to do that. It hurts. But some people think it's a part of professional behavior.
- shpongled 6y agoI'm certainly not going to argue against your points here, since I agree with them, by and large. I personally am not a fan of FB or Palantir, and I suspect I dislike the surveillance state more than the average HN reader. My comment was more on his word choice (which I find to be a bit hyperbolic)
- gwbas1c 6y ago> Painfully, some of the very founding contributors to Haskell itself are the ones deepest involved in this ring The author's point is the opposite. He's calling out prominent members of the Haskell community for running cryptocurrency schemes.
- fwip 6y agoTools are not inherently morally neutral, and I wish that people would stop repeating this lie. Slot machines are expressly designed to feed on a person's gambling addiction and to take their money. Dirty bombs are designed to murder thousands or millions of innocent civilians. The Nazi gas chambers were designed to slaughter millions of innocent civilians. Using a programming language benefits that programming language. This is pretty transparently obvious - a larger community means more skilled professionals, more support on stack overflow, more funding for development, and more open-source contributions. If you strongly believe that the crypto-currency people are doing evil, it makes sense not to aid them. Whether "using Haskell" is worth worrying about is something for individuals to decide on their own. But it's absurd to say that there is no ethical dilemma in incentivizing the development of a tool that is used for evil.
- tome 6y agoThose things don't sound like tools to me. Better examples would be hammers, screwdrivers, etc..
- smadge 6y agoWhere in the article did the author give any advice on using or not using Haskell? The article was criticizing the Haskell community, of which the author is a member, not Haskell as a tool.
- callamdelaney 6y ago`Computers themselves were initially designed for artillery fire control, with an explicit intention of killing people.` any citation for this?
- jhayward 6y ago"The first fully functioning electronic digital computer to be built in the U.S. was ENIAC, constructed at the Moore School of Electrical Engineering, University of Pennsylvania, for the Army Ordnance Department, by J. Presper Eckert and John Mauchly. Completed in 1945, ENIAC was somewhat similar to the earlier Colossus, but considerably larger and more flexible (although far from general-purpose). The primary function for which ENIAC was designed was the calculation of tables used in aiming artillery. ENIAC was not a stored-program computer, and setting it up for a new job involved reconfiguring the machine by means of plugs and switches. For many years, ENIAC was believed to have been the first functioning electronic digital computer, Colossus being unknown to all but a few."[1] [1] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/computing-history/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/computing-history/
- heinrich5991 6y ago> to be built in the U.S. What about the global situation? Is it the same?
- thereticent 6y agoThe UK had Colossus a bit earlier, which I believe was the first fully electronic digital computer.
- yesbabyyes 6y agoDon't forget about Konrad Zuse's Z3!
- jhayward 6y agoIn addition to the digital computers in the 2nd half, analog computers for naval guns were commonly fielded in the early parts of the 20th century.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rangekeeper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rangekeeper
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoThat is not the core argument though? Nobody uses C in order to make their nukes more marketable. Crypto uses the academic big-brain alpha-nerd reputation of Haskell to make their platform appear more reputable. „Look, written by 100% organic PHD-certified FP programmers, raised on our free-range Monad Farm. Oh btw our whitepapers are Very Legit and definitely not just decorum for an ICO scam.“
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- karmakaze 6y agoThese examples are not similar to what is being discussed. Each of those were more commonly used in areas other than the cited ones. The current discussion is more similar to how Python has become strongly associated with machine learning. Anyone who cares about the Haskell language and ecosystem should do what they can to avoid it gaining a strong association with questionable crypto or other areas that will negatively impact wider adoption. This will also become a personal association whether warranted or not. This can be through promoting use in those wider areas or as this post does call attention to specific ones that the community should carefully consider rather than participate, because hey Haskell. It's like Haskell's Manhattan Project--choose wisely with eyes open.