4 ms·
I haven't heard of anyone suggesting any legal strategy by which they can win. I've really been scratching my head trying to figure out what their overall stra
by crazygringo 6y ago
I haven't heard of anyone suggesting any legal strategy by which they can win.
I've really been scratching my head trying to figure out what their overall strategy with this has been.
- nickff 6y agoIt looks like they're trying to shame the publishers, perhaps in the hopes that 'cancel culture' will benefit IA.
- CM30 6y agoFor better or worse, that probably is a more and more plausible strategy to deal with lawsuits and threats nowadays. If you can get enough people to vocally support you over the other side, paint the parties suing you as bullies going after the little guy, make it a giant media controversy that gets hundreds of newspaper articles and YouTube videos etc, then a large number of corporations will probably back down/drop the lawsuit. After all, reputation is king, and companies fear a PR disaster more than just about anything. Whether that'd actually work for the IA on the other hand... well that's a whole different story.
- a1369209993 6y ago> I've really been scratching my head trying to figure out what their overall strategy with this has been. They're doing what's right, with - it appears - insufficient concern for pragmatism.
- paulcole 6y agoTotally disagree that they’re doing what’s right here. They did what they wanted to and thought they’d be able to get away with it. They still might, who knows.
- jjcon 6y ago> They're doing what's right Stealing from artists and authors is right? Just because a company you admire does something wrong doesn’t mean you need to resort to a fanboyish defense. More than 90% of libraries already have digital lending programs that they established legally following all the rules. IA completely disregarded these processes not to mention publishers and authors rights - they just opted to distribut pirated copies of works.
- devenblake 6y agoThoughts cannot be stolen, nor can words on a page, nor can bits and bytes. For something to be stolen, the single instance of that object must be transferred from one entity to another. In this scenario, the existing book was copied from one entity to another. You may believe the Internet Archive was committing an act of theft, but your notions of what theft is are based on an obsolete idea of what property can be.
- jjcon 6y ago> but your notions of what theft is are based on an obsolete idea of what property can be You mean based on internationally recognized standards and laws, unlike your stance which is based on hot air. Seriously, where do you even come up with this stuff? Are you one of those sovereign citizen types?
- jachee 6y agoJust because something is a law, does not mean it is what's right.
- jjcon 6y agoTrue in a general sense - but when countries and cultures all around the world recognize something as important... you might want to question yourself when you disagree.
- jachee 6y agoNot when those countries' leaderships are under the sway of large groups of professional middle-men, who seem to only leech value and litigate, while playing favorites and holding hostage work produced by others with no substantive contribution to the greater good of society.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]