4 ms·
This really doesn’t matter because the work was duplicated regardless of the fact that it was time limited. They had a limited number of licenses to produce wor
by Spivak 6y ago
This really doesn’t matter because the work was duplicated regardless of the fact that it was time limited. They had a limited number of licenses to produce works and they produced more than that. Doesn’t matter if it was for 5 days or 5 minutes.
If I own a DVD and distribute more than copy simultaneously even if it’s time limited and even if I keep the DRM I’ve still violated copyright.
- nitrogen 6y agoPhysical books do not come with licenses. Lending falls under first sale doctrine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 6y agoRight, but digital lending looks a lot more like software licenses where libraries buy "seats" that correspond the number of simultaneous borrowers. If you have more borrowers than seats you've violated copyright. Most libraries work with publishers to buy lending rights directly but IA is arguing that if I hold one physical copy of a work and promise not to "perform" (copyright jargon is odd) it while it's in my possession then I may transmit that work digitally to another person kinda bridging first sale and seats of digital lending licenses. I guess we'll find out if the court buys it. Because under normal circumstances this is open and shut copyright violation.