3 ms·

To the consumer, maybe Pirate Bay and a library and reading in a book store look the same, but behind the scenes they are very different. For a library or readi

To the consumer, maybe Pirate Bay and a library and reading in a book store look the same, but behind the scenes they are very different. For a library or reading in a book store, the store has paid the publisher for the book you are reading. They can only let as many people read as copies they have purchased. In Pirate Bay’s case, someone pays for the book (but not necessarily) and then infinite people can read. Same thing to a consumer maybe, but very different to a publisher or to an author. There’s a reason libraries will buy multiple copies of popular books.

nybble41 6y ago
> For … reading in a book store, the store has paid the publisher for the book you are reading. That depends. Most of the time the store has the option of tearing off the cover and reporting it to the publisher as "destroyed unsold" for a refund. That applies no matter how many people may have read it while it was sitting on the shelf. And why must the entire book be treated as a unit? I see no legal reason why a library could not cut off the binding and lend out chapters or individual pages from the book to patrons on demand, which would allow multiple patrons to read (different parts of) the same book simultaneously. You could easily have 20 or more people reading the same book without major conflicts if you can pass the pages around quickly enough.