5 ms·
Stop Lying About What You Do
- dwc 16y agoI'm not sure what to make of this ramble. I eat meat; I'm nowhere close to vegetarian. I'm pretty ok with that. I have 2 TVs. Both are connected to DVD players, and have no antenna or cable connections. I read a lot, and finish books. I try not to lie to myself, and when I catch myself doing it I try to come clean. So...
- zdw 16y agoSome context: The author is a writer, and his blog often covers both writing and the publishing industry. What he's getting at is that often we idealize our actions, and then act in ways that go against these ideals, thus the lying part. Most of the examples given are of this nature. The other part is that new technology is allowing these changes to happen sooner than people consciously perceive and internalize them. Thus, the author exhorts people to analyze their behavior, especially with regards to new technology, and to come to grips with it in a non-kneejerk manner.
- dwc 16y agoYes, it's a pervasive problem. People have enough trouble with this, even in areas where things don't change rapidly. As someone who's lately steeped in science (vocationally) and skepticism (avocationally), I've had to confront some previously unexamined areas of my philosophy. Though I'm naturally more introspective than many, I must say it can be difficult at times. Despite being a writer, the author would do well to read your comment and learn from it. :)
- wazoox 16y agoHe strangely skipped this embarrassing speckle on everyone's guilt : internet porn. Maybe he's not ready, yet, but the numbers are here : everyone consumes tons of internet porn. Oh, not me of course, Good Gracious :)
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoDoesn't say Why we need to stop. If it helps us get thru the day, avoids hurting people, acknowledges what we Should be instead of simply what we are. Maybe there are reasons to stop but the article doesn't go that far.
- bmelton 16y agoI actually like this article, because it's something that I recognized in myself and have tried to overcome. I still find myself reconciling disparate facts, on occasion, and sometimes it's just hard to say "I don't know." Perhaps one of the most epiphanous moments in my life was when I realized that saying "I don't know" is hard to do for most, easy to do for myself, and generally appreciated. "I don't know" is generally regarded as an honest answer, and it's hard to imagine somebody is bullshitting you when they use it. Long story short though, being completely honest with yourself is HARD. The one thing the author gets wrong is in thinking that people tell themselves these lies deliberately. Most of the time it isn't, or it's borne out of a lack of self-understanding. Having the TV on all day, but only ACTIVELY watching the occasional show might lead one to believe that they don't watch much TV. Whether or not I liked Lord of the Rings, there are certainly parts of it that I admired, even though I didn't like the work on the whole. I can be both excited to see the movie, and have low expectations for it at the same time. I can support the Libertarian ideals while, at the same time, questioning whether or not we have enough data to actually know if a free-market capitalist society can ever actually work.
- colomon 16y ago"Recorded music has run its course." Am I completely dense? I utterly fail to understand the quotes on recorded music in the article. I could easily buy "the record industry has run its course," but that's a completely different idea. With the ease of having a recording studio in your home, or carrying around an affordable better-than-CD-quality recording device in your pocket, I would certainly expect recorded music to become even more common, not go the way of the dinosaurs. Did I miss a trend where kids today only listen to live music?
- nolanw 16y agoThe quotes on recorded music in the article are further examples of people lying to themselves about what they do. They're another example of, as the article quotes, "Evidence that doesn’t fit my beliefs is wrong."
- swombat 16y agoStrawman, meet axe.
- rbarooah 16y agoIs it still a strawman if you don't have an opponent?
- swombat 16y agoThat's sort of the whole point. A strawman argument is one where you make up an opponent to better knock it down. "Yes, did you see that man? I just knocked him down good!"
- rbarooah 16y agoI thought a strawman was a rhetorical device where you make up a weak version of your opponents argument and knock that down as a way of winning an argument in the eyes an audience who doesn't spot the flaw you introduced.
- msbarnett 16y agoA strawman argument is one which you specifically constructed for the purposes of knocking it down. A strawman fallacy is a fallacy in which you replace your opponent's actual argument with a strawman argument, and then assert that defeating the strawman argument defeats the opponent.
- warrenwilkinson 16y agoI wonder: are these people lying to themselves, or just lying to him? I eat meat, but if I thought it would upset a vegan who'd brought it up, I'd probably 'enhance' the truth.