12 ms·
The problem is that the Internet Archive demonstrated that controlled digital lending can allow a library to become indistinguishable from Pirate Bay overnight.
by MattGaiser 6y ago
The problem is that the Internet Archive demonstrated that controlled digital lending can allow a library to become indistinguishable from Pirate Bay overnight.
They blew up an uneasy peace and cannot exactly be trusted to adhere to the practice without changing it as they decide.
- ggrrhh_ta 6y agoIn my opinion, they showed that it didn't become Pirate Bay, but rather reasonably and responsibly took over, during a period of emergency, on the duty of their physical counterparts (closed to the public). It rather strengthened its mission.
- MattGaiser 6y agoHad they taken partner library inventory from confirmed closed libraries and allowed that number of books to be lent, then sure. Instead they allowed unlimited borrowing. They fundamentally broke the "controlled" part.
- xhkkffbf 6y agoExactly. It's almost insulting to everyone to call it "controlled". It's like _1984_'s newspeak.
- acqq 6y agoAFAIK the borrowing was still limited in time and with the DRM protection. Whoever "took" the book at that time lost the access to it long ago already, thanks to the DRM protection remaining and working. Edit: answering "I'm not sure I'd call what they're doing "DRM". Read the court case: explicitly Adobe DRM technology for encrypted e-book formats is mentioned, implemented in different e-book readers and used in this case.
- kevindong 6y agoIf there's no limits on how many copies they would hand out and no limit on how often you can check out the same book, then for practical purposes it's not time limited.
- acqq 6y ago> no limit on how often you can check out the same book There was always a fixed limit on how long the book remains checked out, and it must have already expired to all that checked it out at that time. The DRM protection remained active. Edit: answering the post below: > They had a limited number of licenses to produce works and they produced more than that. It was at the times that all the physical libraries were closed, one can argue that the demand wasn't bigger than what the public libraries would have been able to handle, and even it had been bigger, it was only because of that exceptional emergency happening. But I agree it would have been much clearer had they made some fixed limits corresponding to the estimated number of the books in the physical libraries.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI don't think the fact that physical libraries are closed is relevant, because they weren't loaning out physical books. They were loaning out ebooks, which many (most? All?) libraries had continued to do, totally unaffected by COVID-19
- Spivak 6y agoThis really doesn’t matter because the work was duplicated regardless of the fact that it was time limited. They had a limited number of licenses to produce works and they produced more than that. Doesn’t matter if it was for 5 days or 5 minutes. If I own a DVD and distribute more than copy simultaneously even if it’s time limited and even if I keep the DRM I’ve still violated copyright.
- nitrogen 6y agoPhysical books do not come with licenses. Lending falls under first sale doctrine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoIt's called disrupting the market, I don't see why not. Uber innovated, airbnb innovated and now non profit internet archive.
- MattGaiser 6y agoUber and Airbnb are still in dubious legal territory themselves, especially when it comes to employment/renters rights.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis is ironic because Uber "innovated" by being a taxi service that didn't follow taxi laws and AirBnB "innovated" by being a hotel service that didn't follow hotel laws. Sure enough, the Internet Archive chose to "innovate" libraries with the National Emergency Library, by simply not following copyright laws.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoBut we're a library so it's okay if we make unlimited copies and destroy a business model in the process.
- zucker42 6y agoFacebook destroyed Myspace's business model overnight.
- thechao 6y agoIn the US, there's no right to a business model. That's ridiculous. What's happened is certain bad actors have deliberately taken advantage of a weakness in the social contract to enrich themselves & lock down the ownership of our own culture. At best, we're dealing with moral turpitude, at worst with genuine sociopaths.
- dageshi 6y agoWithout some kind of business model, no writer would be insane enough to write or publish a book because their audience would just read it for free.
- the_af 6y agoThis is mistaken. Writers write. It's their calling. Plenty of writers have been "insane enough" to write and publish without a business model for as long as written language has existed.
- dageshi 6y agoNo, what's mistaken is not noticing that the world has changed. Websites exist, youtube exists, there are a myriad of ways a writer might "write" or create which does not involve book form. Books remain viable because there's a business model to support them, but take that away and people capable of writing could and would go to modern competing products that didn't exist in the past.
- watwut 6y agoI mean, did not reasonably and responsibly took over anything. They decided that they don't care and can do what they want and acted surprised when rights owners objected.
- syshum 6y agoExcept for the fact that is not what they did at all, in no way. Copyright maximalists love to use that argument but it does not make it true. The key point of their response was "physical copies of digitized books do not circulate" during the emergency the Public Libraries where close, thus legal physical copies where not circulating IMO the publishers need to prove the Lending Library loaned more companies of each claimed work, than what was locked away in physical libraries that were closed. if they can do that (they cant) then they have a case, if not they should be tossed out of court
- duxup 6y agoCould I loan out a book that a library isn't circulating... just because I believe it isn't circulating? Obviously IA might have closer ties to libraries than I do, but it's not clear to me what exactly happened that allowed them to loan a ton more. I love IA, but their explanation for what exactly happened regarding loaning library books that were not circulating seemed to me come about ... only after the lawsuit phase started. Their initial announcement seemed to be that there was an emergency and they were loaning out books because libraries (and schools) were closed... but that's not the same thing as an orchestrated digital lending deal that suddenly allowed them to loan a lot more than they had in the past. A lot of explanations from IA seem to have been either poorly communicated, or sort of dance around this idea that they were doing digital lending properly... but without actually saying what they were doing...
- jawns 6y ago> The publishers need to prove the Lending Library loaned more [copies] of each claimed work than what was locked away in physical libraries that were closed. The Internet Archive suddenly gets the right to distribute books owned by a public library simply because the public library is closed? Who struck up that deal? The publishers need only show that the Lending Library loaned more copies of each claimed work than what the Internet Archive owned and had the right to lend. That is sufficient to establish they engaged in uncontrolled digital lending, which is indistinguishable from piracy for all practical purposes.
- 6y ago
- ramshorns 6y agoI think there's a thought experiment here to demonstrate why the national emergency library was fine. Imagine if, the day they closed their doors for the pandemic, all the libraries figured that access to knowledge is still essential and the best way to keep loaning books is digitally. So the libraries mailed all their books to IA on loan, or maybe they digitized them themselves and loaned copies one-for-one to IA. IA would then have more than enough copies to lend out, one at a time per physical book like normal, to everyone who's needed them. The books exist, they're just behind closed doors now.
- jjcon 6y ago> The books exist, they're just behind closed doors now. Every library I’ve used in the states (from rural Georgia to Seattle metro) already has a digital lending system.
- dublinben 6y agoTypical digital lending programs are artificially crippled by publishers. They require libraries to purchase expensive licenses that are worse than physical books, like being subject to embargoes or expiring after only 52 lends.[0] This is why every traditional library's digital catalog is a tiny fraction of their physical inventory. The IA merely allowed people to borrow books that exist in physical form with the convenience that modern digital technology allows. [0]https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/11/publishers-should-be-making-e-book-licensing-better-not-worse https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/11/publishers-should-be-m...
- bsanr 6y agoCrucially, AFAIK digital lending systems aren't based on the number of physical copies a library owns; they're separate licenses. Thus, in a scenario where a physical library is closed but digital lending is still available, a significant portion of the library's catalog is inaccessible. At least in this regard, IA's logic is sound: practically-speaking, the number of copies of a given book that they lent during the period in question almost certainly never exceeded the number of copies held by closed libraries in the US.
- xhkkffbf 6y agoExactly. I support what the IA does with web sites because they don't do it in a way that hurts the web sites. But this is a direct decision to turn into something that's indistinguishable from Pirate Bay. It's almost mocking to call this "controlled digital lending" because it's uncontrolled. There's no limit to the number of books being circulated. As an author, this will be yet another reason not to write books. The only people who will be able to afford to write will be the independently wealthy and the hobbyists. It's sad to watch the IA descend into such anti-artist hatred. Copyright is like a union for writers. To see them become a copyright denialist is so sad.
- MattGaiser 6y agoOr every book will require a sponsor/need to promote something. That is what I really fear. Every book becomes a more subtle advertising piece.
- njharman 6y agoBooks music art all flourished just fine before copyright was invented.
- Silhouette 6y agoThat is debatable. We remember a few high-profile works that have stood the test of time, but how many Mozart symphonies or Mona Lisas has human society produced in its past, and how does that compare with the quality and quantity of new works produced today?
- hombre_fatal 6y agoYet the works everyone wants to actually consume aren't the weekendware creative-commons hobby projects, so it's clear to me that copyright (well, IP in general) is responsible for the most compelling content. Nothing is stopping people from releasing their passion projects to the world without strings attached.
- mcguire 6y ago
- wolco 6y agoThe problem is information wants to be read and be free. Copyright is a wall around information that has already been thought of and recorded. Pirate Bay is exactly like a local libruary which is like a book store. The only difference is physical books vs digital, if you have to give it back and when and the cost. Book stores will let you violate the publishers copyright as long as you don't leave the store. Want to read that entire book, sit on a chair and read. A libruary will let you read at the place or at home but you have to bring it back in a week. Piratebay lets you read it forever but it's a digital copy. All scenerios you can read without paying.
- ramshorns 6y agoWell, reading a book doesn't violate copyright even if you do it inside a bookstore.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoTo the consumer, maybe Pirate Bay and a library and reading in a book store look the same, but behind the scenes they are very different. For a library or reading in a book store, the store has paid the publisher for the book you are reading. They can only let as many people read as copies they have purchased. In Pirate Bay’s case, someone pays for the book (but not necessarily) and then infinite people can read. Same thing to a consumer maybe, but very different to a publisher or to an author. There’s a reason libraries will buy multiple copies of popular books.
- nybble41 6y ago> For … reading in a book store, the store has paid the publisher for the book you are reading. That depends. Most of the time the store has the option of tearing off the cover and reporting it to the publisher as "destroyed unsold" for a refund. That applies no matter how many people may have read it while it was sitting on the shelf. And why must the entire book be treated as a unit? I see no legal reason why a library could not cut off the binding and lend out chapters or individual pages from the book to patrons on demand, which would allow multiple patrons to read (different parts of) the same book simultaneously. You could easily have 20 or more people reading the same book without major conflicts if you can pass the pages around quickly enough.
- sildur 6y agoRight. Then I’m glad I never stopped pirating content.