4 ms·
> His team found that instant coffee comes out best, but that capsules are the runner up in the environmental impact stakes. Filter or drip coffee comes third,
by dragontamer 6y ago
> His team found that instant coffee comes out best, but that capsules are the runner up in the environmental impact stakes. Filter or drip coffee comes third, while traditional espresso has the worst environmental impact. “The impact, such as greenhouse gas emissions, water and fertiliser use, mostly occurs where the coffee is grown,” says Hill. “Capsules tend to need less coffee input to make a single drink and so their overall impact can be lower even though we see more waste when we throw them away.”
I find it difficult to believe that the 2 tablespoons-of-coffee per 8-oz cup has a bigger environmental impact than the plastic-bit.
I think I see the argument, but its hard for me to agree to it.
EDIT: Hmm... there's a cool heuristic that I always go back to whenever we start measuring small things. Assume all weights have the same environmental impact: because the biggest user of greenhouse gasses is the truck (or boat, or train) used to transport the material.
EDIT: So 2-tablespoons of coffee weighs ~10-grams. The article quotes 5.7 grams of coffee per capsule. How heavy is the capsule? If the capsule itself is 4.3 grams (or less), then maybe you're saving energy on transportation costs.
EDIT: My bet however, is that a bag of coffee beans delivers the greatest coffee-to-weight ratio and is the most environmentally sound. Coffee Filters are extremely light, and there are steel mesh reusable filters if you care about the environmental impact of disposable paper filters.
-----------
> Aside from the environmental impact of growing beans in the first place, the second biggest hit is the energy it takes to brew coffee. That’s why barista-made espresso fares so badly in terms of its environmental footprint: a lot of energy is needed to brew just a tiny single espresso cup. Capsules, on the other hand, are more efficient. The coffee machines only flash-heat the amount of water needed for one portion, unlike, for example, boiling a kettle.
Cold brew for the win? I actually prefer cold brew whenever I do things myself for taste reasons. (Less bitterness). Cold brew is also more convenient: I pull it out of the fridge, then drink without any wait time.
----------
> Sebastien Humbert, an expert in life-cycle assessment studies at Quantis, a company that works with many organisations to improve their sustainability, cautions that if you take a responsible consumer — not an average consumer — then it is possible to make drip-filter coffee with less negative impact than capsules, albeit just ever so slightly. “However, if you are an irresponsible consumer, if your drip filter machine is very inefficient, if you leave it on, if you make more coffee than necessary, then you can make drip-filter coffee significantly worse than capsules,” he says.
Okay: so it seems like they're assuming irresponsible and wasteful behavior on behalf of drip-coffee makers.
- gen3 6y ago> Okay: so it seems like they're assuming irresponsible and wasteful behavior on behalf of drip-coffee makers. Not to mention it ignores the other ways of consuming coffee, such as pour-over or French press.
- softwaredoug 6y agoI think they are saying that in those cases, you'll likely boil a whole pot of water, which takes a lot of energy compared to flash-heating just the water needed. I didn't see a comparison to automatic espresso machines, which I would assume would be similar in energy/water use to a capsule maker, but without the capsule waste.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe last time I made hot coffee for myself, I microwaved one cup of water, then used a pour over. But again, I normally Cold Brew. That's room temperature for 24 hours, which is less bitter than hot brewing. In this cold Brew case, I don't use any energy heating the water. I guess I use fridge space but I don't think additional items in the fridge contributes to energy usage... ---------- I got coworkers who prefer a french press. I don't think they microwave much more than one cup of water.
- gambiting 6y agoI make all of my coffee in a mokka pot, every morning - so it boils exactly as much water as fits in my mug, nothing more. And it doesn't consume any materials, the whole thing is stainless steel with a rubber gasket which I just rinse under the tap after every use.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoAye, same here. Rubber gaskets last a long time, too. I've replaced them once in 5 years. You can get a 3-pack off of Amazon for like ~$8 bucks or less. Don't have to boil tons of water, not tossing out anything except grounds, and generally get a better coffee than via drip. As as of the grounds: I have an old coffee tin, one of the big ole "chock fulla nuts" ones, that I put the old grounds in. Eventually they end up in a compost pile outside, with all of my veggie choppings and lawn clippings.