4 ms·
Monthly and quaterly figures are bound to show the largest drop. For annual figures, a first approximation is that a month is worth 1/12th of the annual output
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
Monthly and quaterly figures are bound to show the largest drop.
For annual figures, a first approximation is that a month is worth 1/12th of the annual output so I would expect a 8.3% drop for every month that the economy is completely stopped.
34% contraction for a quarter means that the economy essentially stopped for a whole month, and would lead to a 8% contraction for 2020, everything else being equal. But we're not through yet...
- coldpie 6y ago> I would expect 8.3% drop for every month that the economy is completely stopped Yeah. Everyone knew this was going to be bad, which is why the experts were saying we need to get it under control quickly and figure out how to safely operate while the pandemic is in effect. But 2016 happened, so instead we get months and months of lockdown and the accompanying economic devastation.
- dageshi 6y agoHistory isn't going to be kind to Trump.
- gtfoutttt 6y agoThe present isn't too kind to him either.
- atemerev 6y agoThe "experts" are saying many different things. Currently, the new situation is being analyzed, but it seems that even pervasive non-pharmaceutical interventions (masks obligatory in all closed spaces, ban on public events, etc) are still not enough to keep Rt below 1.0 and "get it under control" (see the second wave effects in Europe). Lockdowns seemed to work, but economically unsustainable. As of now, there is no clear answer about how to proceed. And that's before the epic blame game even started. Boy, that would be interesting to watch.
- rorykoehler 6y agoMasks would work if everybody wore them
- tmountain 6y agoAnd, wore them properly.
- atemerev 6y agoI was in southern France recently. Nearly 100% of people there are wearing masks inside shops, public transport, and other confined spaces. And still, even there we now see the clear increase in daily cases (it is much slower than before, but still happening)
- DanBC 6y agoThere's no (edit to add: good} evidence for that.
- glofish 6y agothe problem is that masks have a minor effect at best thus in no way represent the solution so many seek
- atemerev 6y agoNot “a minor effect”, they seem to improve Rt more or less significantly (according to preliminary studies). But they are probably not enough on their own.
- Gwypaas 6y agoThis feels like such an American solution. If everyone just does this one magic thing then life will continue on as usual. First it was hydroxychloroquine, then a lock-down and now masks. Masks worn correctly limits spread, but it's just a piece in the puzzle of tools available, and almost certainly not the most significant one, that is not meeting people. Look at Finland, Norway and Denmark, they all successfully controlled it so far without mask usage. Catching up with research they now encourage it in indoor situations where you can't distance, even though the recommendation still is to not even be there if possible. Leaving it as a tool available if current measures aren't enough.
- makomk 6y agoThe trouble is, there's no good reason to believe that it's even possible to get Covid-19 under control. The handful of success stories that everyone pointed to kept on turning out not to be: Singapore, arguably South Korea, Australia, Hong Kong, Vietnam... and the press just kept on moving on to the next one without ever changing the narrative. We've never contained a respiratory disease this contagious and sneaky before; historically, they've just run through the population and efforts have been focused on minimizing the damage. Unfortunately 2016 happened and now it's an election year again, so we need the idea that all this economic damage and death and lockdowns could've been avoided if only Trump wasn't in charge in order to ensure the right candidate wins later this year.
- take_a_breath 6y ago== For annual figures, a first approximation is that a month is worth 1/12th of the annual output so I would expect 8.3% drop for every month that the economy is completely stopped.== It’s not that easy as the US economy was never “completely stopped”. Public services did not stop, grocery stores did not stop, etc. Even today the states have various levels of openness and movement.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> It’s not that easy as the US economy was never “completely stopped” Yes, 8.3% is obviously the upper bound and in practice it will always be less per month since the economy will never completely stop. The figure is to provide a ballpark estimate of what to expect and also to estimate how much the economy was impacted.