3 ms·
I was actually surprised that no one else posted excerpts from the Apple Developer Agreement[0]. There's millions of copies out there. It clearly states that A
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I was actually surprised that no one else posted excerpts from the Apple Developer Agreement[0]. There's millions of copies out there.
It clearly states that Apple is entitled to do what was originally tweeted, but, from a lot of anecdotal stories by developers that have actually processed refunds (I am not one. I have never processed a refund), Apple does not actually do this.
A few folks have pointed out that, even though the contract stipulates it, the practice may be considered illegal, or at least open to court challenges; which might be why it isn't enforced.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23992510 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23992510
- jjcon 6y agoNo Apple states they are entitled to not refund credit card fees (which they would not get back) - they don’t state they are entitled to not refund the 30% cut
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI don't read that at all: > In the event that Apple refunds any such price to an End-User, You shall reimburse, or grant Apple a credit for, an amount equal to the price for that Licensed Application. In the event that Apple receives any notice or claim from a payment provider that an End-User has obtained a refund for a Licensed Application, You shall reimburse, or grant Apple a credit for, an amount equal to the price for that Licensed Application. In such cases, Apple will have the right to retain its commission on the sale of that Licensed Application, notwithstanding the refund of the price to the End-User. "an amount equal to the price for that Licensed Application" sounds like we're on the hook for the full nut. "In such cases, Apple will have the right to retain its commission on the sale of that Licensed Application, notwithstanding the refund of the price to the End-User." Sounds like they get to keep the 30%, no matter what. Like I said, it may not be enforceable, in the real world, but that's what the agreement I have, says, verbatim.
- DangerousPie 6y agoIsn't this about user-initiated chargebacks through the CC provider rather than developer-initiated refunds? Or am I reading this wrong? > any notice or claim from a payment provider that an End-User has obtained a refund
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI think that the only way to get an app (or a refund), is via some payment gateway, so I assume that Apple is indicating that this is the "official" way they are notified of a refund. It may be that they don't consider the refund "complete," until ack'ed by the gateway.
- sirn 6y agoYou can asked for refund via Apple Support. I've done this several times. The refund have to go through payment gateway in any case, but when a refund request comes from payment gateway (or notified by, in the TOS' wording), it is a chargeback and there's a fee associated with it. From the customer side of things, calling their credit card company to have a refund and calling the merchant to have a refund may have the same result, however in the merchant side of things they are completely different with the former result in a penalty for the merchant (chargeback ratio).
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThat makes sense. I don't see any language that talks about chargeback fees, so it is my assumption that Apple will eat them. I'm pretty sure that the "merchant," in this case, is Apple, so they would need to eat the chargebacks. I don't think that anyone is well-served by refunds. It damages Apple's brand, it damages the developer's brand, it pisses off the customer, and generally makes life miserable for everyone. Even the payment processor is unhappy. I suspect that if any knucklehead tried to "refund-bomb" a developer, Apple would step on that fairly quickly.
- 6y ago
- gridlockd 6y agoIt literally says "commission", which is the 30% cut.
- ShroudedNight 6y agoNotwithstanding how Apple actually behaves, it seems the legal situation over this clause was at the very least ambiguous, with some parties interpreting it as you do, more than a decade ago: https://techcrunch.com/2009/03/25/apples-iphone-app-refund-policies-could-bankrupt-developers/ https://techcrunch.com/2009/03/25/apples-iphone-app-refund-p...
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThanks for that link! I seem to remember the kvetching about that, back then.