4 ms·
You're expecting UBI to also fix the lack of democracy? That's a separate problem, that definitely also needs to be addressed. UBI is just to prevent poor peopl
by mcv 6y ago
You're expecting UBI to also fix the lack of democracy? That's a separate problem, that definitely also needs to be addressed. UBI is just to prevent poor people from starving while rewarding working your way up out of poverty. It's not the magical supercure for all society's ills. Those need their own solutions.
Like proportional representation, approval voting, banning corporate money from politics, etc.
- TomMarius 6y agoWhat I am saying is that expecting UBI to transfer power to the employees while these problems still exist might not go too well. I don't expect UBI to be perfect from the get go, and I don't expect these other problems to be solved within the next decade - so what now? Do we condone poor people (that have absolutely no way to fight back) to the whims of a corrupt government for a decade or more because it might get better sometimes in the future?
- mcv 6y agoThey already are. It's not something that's changing because of UBI. And if it's truly a UBI, then it will be a lot harder to deny people that basic income than it currently is with welfare and social security.
- TomMarius 6y agoIMHO it's a lot harder to deny a concrete, targeted entitlement than a super-wide payment for everyone without a reason/need that might just get reduced to nothing over time.
- mcv 6y agoIt's much easier to deny that people meet a very specific set of criteria required for such a targeted entitlement, than to deny that they are citizens and alive.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoUBI is just to prevent poor people from starving while rewarding working your way up out of poverty I don’t think most people in poverty will work their way out of it. It’s a mindset and a lifestyle, in addition to a reality. UBI probably won’t change that. It’s an interesting thought experiment: can you have a society without impoverished people? Not starving, though, is something that can be directly impacted with UBI.
- bmitc 6y ago> I don’t think most people in poverty will work their way out of it. It’s a mindset and a lifestyle, in addition to a reality. The way "it's a mindset and a lifestyle" reads is very harsh and diminishes the complexity of why poor people stay poor.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoBut is it mistaken?
- bmitc 6y agoYes, in the same way that saying wealthy people are wealthy because of their mindset and lifestyle choices is mistaken.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoIt seems true to say that wealthy people stay wealthy because of their mindset and lifestyle choices.
- HPsquared 6y agoSurely that statement adds another layer of complexity - the aspect of lifestyle and mindset - to the basic definition of simply being low on capital.
- bmitc 6y ago