5 ms·
So grandma who lives on a lot with a single family home gets a $50,000 annual tax bill to incentivize the building of a 400 unit apartment building?
by refurb 6y ago
So grandma who lives on a lot with a single family home gets a $50,000 annual tax bill to incentivize the building of a 400 unit apartment building?
- rcpt 6y agoSo tax cuts for every successful property investor because grandma is a successful property investor?
- refurb 6y agoSome people seem to suggest that but I don’t. Only calling out the problem with taking someone’s property tax and increasing it 5-10x.
- rcpt 6y agoIf their property went up 5-10x that's a huge win for them.
- refurb 6y agoBut that’s not the discussion. A land value tax captures pretty much all the value of the land. So a prime spot in a major city might cost $500,000 but have annual property taxes of $100,000. The goal is to make the land unattractive unless you optimize the use of the land and build high density.
- rcpt 6y ago> The goal is to make the land unattractive unless you optimize the use of the land and build high density. That's right and it should be that way. The value of the land is a function of the success of the local community - it shouldn't be captured by a private investor while workers continue to pay income taxes to service and improve that land. But if your only objection is that elderly/disabled landowners shouldn't be pressured to pay taxes many states already have laws like that in place, eg https://www.state.nj.us/treasury/taxation/ptr/ https://www.state.nj.us/treasury/taxation/ptr/
- tornato7 6y agoYeah, this is currently a big problem with property tax in some places and a land value tax would only make it worse. I think it would accelerate the move to big multi-story apartment buildings that can get more revenue per sq.ft of land. Which I guess if you're worried about the housing crisis could be a good thing.
- kfarr 6y agoYeah: feature not a bug
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoGrandma can have one of the new apartments, and the other 399 can go to people who otherwise would have been homeless. Or more realistically, for every grandma who owns a single-family home in manhattan, there are a million property speculators sitting on vacant lots.
- coryrc 6y agoYes, if her taxes are that high, she can sell her property for millions. I don't feel bad for millionaires having to pay taxes.
- refurb 6y agoSo you'd force her out of her home? You realize granny and all the other homeowners would never vote for that or the politicians that support it?
- diffeomorphism 6y agoHer million dollar home? > You realize millionaires would never vote for that or the politicians that support it? So? What percentage of the electorate consists of millionaires?
- refurb 6y agoAmong SF homeowners? Most!
- diffeomorphism 6y agoI thought the US got rid of property qualifications for voting in 1856? Or why are you restricting to "among SF homeowners"?
- mennis16 6y agoI don't know how the numbers work out but I imagine there are enough people using property as an investment that the above could be implemented with an exception for 1 single family home per tax household, and still generate a lot of money. I agree it sucks to force people out of their primary residence, even if they would be nicely compensated. But residential property should be more focused on the residential part than it is these days.
- xapata 6y agoIf she's living on a prime plot, yes. "I was here first!" only sounds fair to toddlers. She'll be able to live in comfort (probably with more comfort) elsewhere with the proceeds from the sale.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dangjc 6y agoThere are grandmas around me in the bay area who own houses worth $1mm they bought for $100k. That means they made $900k. They can afford to pay the $10k in property taxes for 90 years, as long as we give them the option to defer paying until they sell the property and cash in. If it’s a $10k land value tax, they can construct an ADU on the property and not have their taxes go up. Seems like a good incentive structure to help the housing shortage.
- spyckie2 6y agoso basically, the grandma can't rely on the property to pass it down to their kids, or support their living? If they sell it won't that just mean they have to pay 800k in taxes on their 1m house and then have to find another house for $1m? Some things don't really add up.
- boomlinde 6y ago> or support their living? Ideally, IMO. Simply owning land is not a meaningful contribution to society. Rent from land ownership therefore disincentivizes meaningful contributions to society by creating reliable sources of income to those that don't contribute, disproportionately among the rich (who otherwise have the best means to contribute) because they disproportionately own land from which they can extract rent. > If they sell it won't that just mean they have to pay 800k in taxes on their 1m house and then have to find another house for $1m? Well, if land value was taxed on sale, grandma could just sit on the property until she died and not be affected by the policy at all. This is IMO not ideal because much of land value will then be lost until the next generation comes along. LVT should instead be collected on a regular basis. Ideally, with single-tax LVT, land value is completely consumed by taxes. Any money grandma makes on the sale will be from the value of her own development and the excess value over land value the buyer expects. That said, I believe that there are important criticisms that can be raised against Georgism. I believe that it would have to be accompanied by strict zoning laws to avoid displacing people and exploiting natural resources. I'm less concerned about grandma's little house than I am about a tax that makes things like fracking or deforestation to extract what makes the land valuable inevitable.
- 6y ago
- stale2002 6y agoIf people really want, there are common provisions in laws that protect old people who have lived in a place for a long time, but still has these land taxes.
- malkuth23 6y agoIn my state of Louisiana, there is a homestead exemption where if the property is your primary residence, you are exempt from a good chunk of property taxes. It doesn't always make it zero and it doesn't stop taxes from rising at a somewhat reasonable rate (though some would disagree), but it keeps it from having the California problem of taxes being essentially fixed at the purchase price while still protecting owner occupants. There are lots of other variations on this that work just fine.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoGrandma moves to an apartment, her children move to apartments, her grandchildren move to apartments. Apartments are now actually affordable. Otherwise your argument is "children and grandchildren of her everybody else pay $50,000 annual tax so she can keep living in this single family home and god forbid it were a multi-family or apartment building".