2 ms·
> My diagnosis; the profession of software development is a victim of a hostile takeover from product managers, while pushing engineers out of control of their
by tristor 6y ago
> My diagnosis; the profession of software development is a victim of a hostile takeover from product managers, while pushing engineers out of control of their domain.
I do not agree, but I am biased. I'm a former engineer with a security focus that is now a product manager.
I think a more honest take is that security has never been a priority outside of some specialized use cases/industries and that didn't improve as software development moved from something esoteric to something which is business critical in every industry vertical. Even in industry verticals where security is theoretically a priority and a lot of money is spent on security, most of the "security" people don't actually know anything about security and most of the work is box-checking for compliance audits.
You can only do so much and if we're being real security will always compete with other development priorities and the ones which drive revenue always win in any for profit enterprise which creates software as a core competency and the ones which reduce cost always win in any for profit enterprise where software creation is not their core function. Tech is either a product/revenue driver, or it's a cost center, and in both cases security adds additional expense, overhead, and time to release timelines which doesn't pass the PHB smell test.
The other big issue is that security doesn't have strong advocates in most organizations because even the most technical people in most organizations are security illiterate, even in the tech industry vertical. As a SWE at most companies you're a "security genius" if you use a password manager and know how to generate a CSR with OpenSSL or configure Let's Encrypt.
Maybe I'm overly cynical, but I've largely given up on seeing most companies pursue security with the passion and commitment necessary and see policy as the proper way to address these concerns. I applaud things like HITRUST CSF, which is strongly prescriptive and helps drive security in industries where every single company is full of box-checkers who like to buy appliances. I've been fortunate enough to work at companies that take security seriously and appreciate my background and as a product manager I have always considered user security and privacy to be critical and core components of UX in my products. So, I wouldn't blame the PMs, I'd blame the realities of doing business combined with the lack of adequate security literacy across the board in every industry vertical and at every technical role level.