3 ms·
This is why Booker/West-style baby bonds could have a significant chance to alleviate structural poverty. Beyond a certain threshold (and I think we’re past tha
by rayiner 6y ago
This is why Booker/West-style baby bonds could have a significant chance to alleviate structural poverty. Beyond a certain threshold (and I think we’re past that in the US) equality of opportunity (better education, etc.) won’t make up for starting out poor. What people need is seed capital.
For a fraction of the cost of universal healthcare, we could endow each child born in the US with a $250,000 trust fund at birth. That would be game changing.
- jeffbee 6y agoWhat would be the point of such trust funds? Assuming they were not intended to pay out until higher education (age 18?) it would just look exactly like Social Security: a supposedly-funded massive future liability that the federal budget borrows against and/or repeatedly attempts to privatize. Except your idea would receive even higher contributions than Social Security does.
- rayiner 6y agoAre you asking what people would be able to use $250k for?
- jeffbee 6y agoNo, I'm asking why it would be structured like that. It seems like an open invitation to just raid and squander it. If you took the same amount of money you could, just as an example, permanently endow a professional educator for every 20 births, which begins paying off right away, instead of decades later.
- rayiner 6y agoI think spending the money on a “professional educator” would be squandering it. This country has huge inequities, and I don’t think you can solve it by throwing money at college educated (disproportionately white) people.
- tptacek 6y agoEspecially in postsecondary education, which is artificially limited and will absorb some factor of all the additional subsidies it's given.
- jgalt212 6y agoGiven the student loan crisis, the supply seems to be artificially unlimited, not restricted.
- tptacek 6y agoYou're talking about the supply of dollars, I'm talking about the supply of university admissions slots.
- jgalt212 6y agoOne is a proxy for the other. There is $1.5T [1] in total outstanding student debt. There would not be such a large amount without a number of factors, but the most important piece of this puzzle is the number of students and that correlates 1:1 to with admission slots. So as I originally posited, there are enough admission slots (probably way too many given default rates) at the aggregate level. Maybe there are not enough admission slots at MIT and other similarly impressive schools, but in the aggregate there are probably too many admission slots. So "university admission slots", as you stated without any qualifiers, has an oversupply. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_debt#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_debt#United_States
- tptacek 6y agoStrong disagree; this is a repeated pattern with subsidies in regulated/controlled industries: subsidy increases demand, and supply doesn't automatically scale to meet the demand. When's the last time we added a new competitive 4-year university? Ave Maria?
- luckylion 6y ago> For a fraction of the cost of universal healthcare, we could endow each child born in the US with a $250,000 trust fund at birth. That would be game changing. But they'd still need to buy health care, only they'd now have to do with while also funding an extra $900bn (per year!) trust fund program, wouldn't they?
- twblalock 6y agoI'd bet a significant number of people, upon turning 18, would learn that their trust fund had been emptied out by their parents.
- tptacek 6y agoAssume that happens, and that no effective countermeasures are derived. How are poor families worse off for having the option in the first place? It's not like Booker is proposing to take the money from some other service offered to the poor: Booker proposed paying for it by increasing taxes on capital gains, which poor people weren't paying to begin with.
- twblalock 6y agoThat's not really the point. Who do you think would be more likely, and more in need, to raid their children's trust funds? This would be yet another program where the poor don't get what was promised to them and the rich do just fine. Rich kids would get their $250k, and poor kids would find out exactly how their parents were able to pay the rent the whole time they were growing up. If you want to help poor kids you need to make sure nobody else can take the money you give them, even though everyone around them has a very strong incentive to take that money. Otherwise you aren’t actually helping who you intend to help.
- akerl_ 6y agoEven the worst case you’re describing sounds like a win to me, relative to the present. If gaming the system looks like “the child doesn’t have to worry about stable housing while growing up”, that seems like an upside. But I’d caution against the idea that lower-income parents are so predisposed to both gaming the system and stealing money from their children, which seems like an unintentional undertone of your comment.
- twblalock 6y ago> If gaming the system looks like “the child doesn’t have to worry about stable housing while growing up”, that seems like an upside. To be clear, you are talking about children's trust funds being raided as a good outcome. How would you feel if that violation of your rights happened to you, and it didn't happen to other children, and then some adult told you that it was ok that it happened?