2 ms·
Suppose you have a 40Mbps vDSL setup, and you bought a $50 "router" to consume the 40Mbps vDSL signal and give you WiFi Internet access. You bought the router f
by tialaramex 6y ago
Suppose you have a 40Mbps vDSL setup, and you bought a $50 "router" to consume the 40Mbps vDSL signal and give you WiFi Internet access. You bought the router from your ISP outright, but it was supplied pre-configured with your username and password and so on because hey, they are your ISP.
A few years later you get fancy 10Gbps fibre Internet from a startup called say "Glass Everywhere" that thinks everybody should be doing live VR sessions. GE provides a new WiFi router, though it's unclear whether you actually own it or it's somehow rented with the service.
You sell the first WiFi router on Craigslist for $30.
The person who buys it does not get 40Mbps vDSL Internet service from your old ISP. Even though the router still has your old credentials for that ISP, you terminated the account weeks ago and it doesn't work.
Courts understand that the WiFi router, and the service it enabled access to, are not the same thing, and that you cannot possibly sell unlimited access to the Internet in the form of a WiFi router, you were just selling this object, and if the purchaser didn't understand what it's for Caveat Emptor because this is a private sale.
The glasses work fine. The "poor sap" got working glasses. The service went away. If you implied the service comes with the glasses, they might very well have a claim on you for it going away, and I'd recommend giving their $600 back, otherwise they got what they paid for, Caveat Emptor.
First Sale has been eroded to the point it's barely worth talking about, but it was never intended to apply to situations like this.