4 ms·
I did not get the explanation for why SMS 2FA does not work against credential stuffing. It clearly does.
by lostmsu 6y ago
I did not get the explanation for why SMS 2FA does not work against credential stuffing. It clearly does.
- UncleMeat 6y agoHe is thinking of it from the user’s perspective rather than the service. If I reuse my passwords I still get owned even if some of my services use 2fa, because others won’t. It’s an unusual way of thinking about it and I think the weakest part of his argument but it is interesting.
- lostmsu 6y agoYeah, that basically destroys his argument. If I use the same password for a random internet forum with no 2FA and my bank account with SMS 2FA, then a person, who breaks into the forum DB still can not access my money.
- ozim 6y agoProblem is that attackers can take advantage of that random internet forum to take over your bank account. Plant something that you would click because it is on your account and it downloads some malware. Could come up with more scenarios probably like they could target someone else from your account and use trust you have on that forum. But it is of course question if you are worth their time.
- lostmsu 6y agoWhat you said has nothing to do with SMS 2FA, and has everything to do with user/their friends' gullibility, which still must be pretty high to click something on the forum and then also launch it. It also is totally unrelated to credential stuffing. We are not looking for a panacea there. If you're that gullible and your forum account is pwned, no security measures will prevent you from giving up bank details.
- 33Backpack33 6y agoIt doesn't stop it but delays it. The attacker seeing a SMS 2FA screen doesn't mean they give up, it just means the user is now more valuable. This explains it https://passwordbits.com/dont-need-sms-2fa/ https://passwordbits.com/dont-need-sms-2fa/