3 ms·
Notice that walking on the streets of China or Hong Kong is still a world different from posting an internet comment or incrementing a mysql column. Also, yes,
by hombre_fatal 6y ago
Notice that walking on the streets of China or Hong Kong is still a world different from posting an internet comment or incrementing a mysql column.
Also, yes, we generally are skeptical of political claims online. See this thread and any political discussion on HN. It's why political submissions are usually clusterfucks like this one where every top-level comment is greyed-out and making a strong claim. Or made by someone who registered an account just to post it.
Either way, you are here bringing Quora posts and a petition in into a superhot discussion that demands more. Linking to published opinion pieces from people at ground zero would definitely be more compelling than pointing us to an internet forum where you write your own byline credentials.
- FooBarWidget 6y agoHere is an actual person, living in China, commenting on Hong Kong. Do you believe this video deserves skepticism? If so, can you tell me why? https://youtu.be/h64hTb4on78 https://youtu.be/h64hTb4on78
- robjan 6y ago-
- kick 6y agoThe Chinese government allows dissent to some degree; "disappearing" of critics isn't universal and shouldn't be seen as such. Criticize it for things it actually does, of which there are many.
- FooBarWidget 6y agoI don't know why your other post was flagged. I just want to say two things in reply. You read too much into why I mentioned "foreigner". I actually wanted to ask whether people consider the video that I posted above, which is made by an actual foreigner (as a fact, not as an insinuation of anything more) can be considered an honest opinion. I also used the word "valid" as a shorthand for "an opinion that deserves to be heard and considered, rather than downvoted or dismissed", for the lack of a better term.
- kick 6y agoIf he's representing his affiliations honestly, why wouldn't it be? Faking video is harder than lying about who you are on the internet. To point back to that comment, Chinese living in China have just as much a right to have opinions on it, and so do Americans living in America, but neither of their opinions are worth half as much as people living in Hong Kong. As long as they're representing themselves honestly (as Chinese or Americans, living in their respective countries), they've still got honest opinions, even if their opinions don't matter as much as the ones of people living in Hong Kong.