5 ms·
I don't think this is their biggest problem. Libro.fm is selling their audiobooks at what appears to be some kind of absurd MSRP. Audible offers audiobooks at
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
I don't think this is their biggest problem. Libro.fm is selling their audiobooks at what appears to be some kind of absurd MSRP.
Audible offers audiobooks at that price point too, but you'd have to be an idiot to pay it. Amazon will sell you the Audible version of a book you've purchased the Kindle version of at a steep discount. So steep that purchasing the ebook+audiobook is cheaper than purchasing the audiobook by itself.
Compare the pricing for All Creatures Great and Small, which is atypical mostly in that the combined-purchase discount is unusually stingy:
Libro.fm: $37.94
Audible: $29.99
Kindle+Audible: $17.48
I don't like buying DRMed audiobooks, but it's not that hard to justify at $2.99.
- throwanem 6y agoUnless you can strip the DRM, you're not buying.
- recursive 6y agoI don't think most audiobook listeners care about this distinction enough to overcome the price difference.
- xtracto 6y agoUntil all their "purchased" books get into the DRM graveyard because in fact they did not purchase anything. I lost access to all my "purchased" Amazon Kindle books when they blocked my account and no amount of calls and explaining allowed me to at least get my "purchased" content. Since then I created r/drmgraveyard to follow up the dead of DRM encumbered services.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThe curse is that, like targeted social engineering, it doesn't happen to enough people enough of the time to change behavior. How many people use Steam knowing and caring that you can't enter offline mode to play your games unless you connect to the internet every month?
- withjive 6y agoIt's actually quite easy to strip the DRM on Audible using ffmpeg - which I do to keep an archive of all my purchases. There's a script on github to get the encryption key for your account by letting it sign in for you. Then from there it's easy to get ffmpeg to turn the DRM aac to a mp3
- errantspark 6y agoIs this legal? I sort of assume it isn't, in which case why bother? It seems faster/easier just to pirate from the get go.
- techsupporter 6y ago> It seems faster/easier just to pirate from the get go Then the author doesn't get paid. That's the difference; buying an encumbered file and removing the encumbrance still pays the creator.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoWhy not borrow audiobooks from a local library?
- techsupporter 6y agoI do, but that's the point of the article, that Amazon/Audible exclusives are not available to libraries for electronic lending. At that point, a prospective customer has two choices: Not buy (which is the choice I largely make), or buy from the sole source and remove the DRM.
- nightfly 6y ago> Then the author doesn't get paid.
- yesenadam 6y agoThe creator presumably gets a very small cut. If you want to pay the creator, why not send the full price, or some amount, directly to them?! I'm sure they would appreciate that.
- TylerE 6y agoIf you listen regularly, the Audible membership is even better... $23/month for two books, and 30% off on everything past that. So that can get the per book cost down to under $12
- gxqoz 6y agoLooks like Libro.fm has a similar subscription service, although it's $15/month for one book. This isn't all that shocking that it's a bit more expensive than Amazon. Hard to beat them on price.
- glial 6y agoYou can set it up so your local bookstore gets a kickback from Libro.fm, too.
- kemiller2002 6y agoAnd if you pay for the year up front, it's even cheaper. (Actually, I think the 1st year offer for 12 audio books is a better deal than that too.)
- mjayhn 6y agoI really hate their dark-pattern of holding your credits hostage if you want to pause your account. I have like 10 credits that I don't want to spend right now, I'm backed up and hardly reading and I can't pause my Audible membership that's $24/mo without losing my credits. I also don't want to be rushed to pick out 10 books and possibly waste my credits so I can pause. I'm VERY picky about what books I burn a credit on. It's a really crappy way of keeping me tied in and I want to make sure people know about it.
- falcolas 6y agoTheir prices is one problem, being completely unable to post a book at the price is another. It's also worth noting that making audiobooks is very labor intensive, and Amazon/Audible can offer some of their prices only via the economies of scale. It's also possible that they're offering books at a loss to push out other audiobook sellers - an extension of their efforts with exclusives.
- deepsun 6y ago> making audiobooks is very labor intensive I don't think it's any way close to writing a book first. But books are priced way cheaper for some reason.
- falcolas 6y agoA 10 hour audiobook (which is about 90k words) requires: - About 20 hours of a voice actor's time - About 40 hours of a sound engineer's time - About 30 hours of a director's time Plus recording booth facilities. Some basic Googling puts the actual cost in excess of $200 per finished hour of recording. Books have a broader distribution than audiobooks, on an order of magnitude (or two) scale. That's the primary reason why they're inexpensive. Audiobooks are still a bit of a niche market, though Audible/Amazon are doing a lot to increase the size of the market. EDIT: I did a bit of research, and it seems like freelance writers can earn between $0.02 to $0.20 per word, which for a 90k novel works out to up to $18,000; less than the finished audio book. Take that how you will.
- HideousKojima 6y ago>A 10 hour audiobook (which is about 90k words) requires I don't think that word means what you think it means. It's completely possible for an author to record their own audiobook in professional quality audio with a fairly minimal investment. If they don't have a good narration voice then that's going to hurt them, but it can all be done by the author themselves at no extra cost apart from their time, a decent microphone, a computer, and a quiet place to record.
- quadrifoliate 6y agoPerhaps they have accepted that consumers will not notice the DRM encumbrance, and are selling to libraries? The post mentions libraries quite a bit, although I'm not clear about the relevant licensing terms when audiobooks are sold to libraries.
- 67868018 6y agoYour membership to Libro.fm gets you one token per month at $15. You can get any audiobook you want with this token. Then any additional audiobooks for the month get you a 30% discount off MSRP It's not that bad, honestly, when compared to Audible which also limits you to one a month + discounted price for additional
- thaumasiotes 6y ago$15 is still several times more than Amazon charges.
- jacobmischka 6y agoUnless by "several" you mean 1.25, then no, it's not.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoLooks like they've raised prices since I last looked. But even at the higher prices, $15 is fully twice as much as Amazon charges, not 1.25x.
- 67868018 6y agoAmazon (Audible) charges $14.95 per month giving you one token / audiobook a month. They're the same price!