3 ms·
Saying that people are being "disappeared into vans" is a blatant mischaracterization. "Disappeared" has a very specific connotation related to Nazi Germany, or
by pc86 6y ago
Saying that people are being "disappeared into vans" is a blatant mischaracterization. "Disappeared" has a very specific connotation related to Nazi Germany, or the USSR, where you literally disappear and are never heard from again. There is not a single case of people actually disappearing. There's a Snopes article elsewhere in the thread that goes into better detail about what is actually happening, and I suggest you read it (or literally any non-internet comment description of it).
It's wrong, a massive federal overreach, and I hope people are prosecuted for it, I but to equate it with the KGB killing people in government facilities or the Nazis shipping people off to camps displays a shocking lack of empathy or even the most basic understanding of history.
- notacoward 6y agoOn the contrary, history teaches us that exactly that kind of "disappearing" is where we're headed if we don't do something to change our trajectory. Perhaps it's hyperbole, but that doesn't justify your insults.
- pc86 6y agoI'm not arguing that that's what's further down the slippery slope we're on. I fully believe that's where we're headed. But that's not where we are today, and the distinction is important. Because once the latter happens, that justifies a completely different response from the populace than what we're facing today.
- perl4ever 6y ago>There is not a single case of people actually disappearing What do you mean by that? Surely people indisputably do disappear from time to time, and we may not know who to blame. Surely we all agree that "secret police" who work for the federal government are doing secret things which sometimes includes grabbing people and releasing them, because the grabbees have been describing it publicly. So what's the sense in asserting the secret police are not disappearing people; how could you possibly rule it out? Conversely if they are disappearing people, without records or badges, it seems unlikely to be easily proven.