4 ms·
>"This is a remarkable bit of framing for a (checks link) news article. It is taken as a given that the big tech companies are akin to big banks after the finan
by Barrin92 6y ago
>"This is a remarkable bit of framing for a (checks link) news article. It is taken as a given that the big tech companies are akin to big banks after the financial crisis, the tobacco industry, and airlines — no wonder there are “long-simmering frustrations”! People must hate Apple, Google, Amazon, and Facebook!
Needless to say, this doesn’t match reality; every year The Verge conducts a tech survey and the results speak for themselves:"
Wrong comparison. During its heyday high finance was actually very popular and bankers had a positive reputation as brave risk takers. In the 80s it was still very much seen as the heart of American capitalism. The demise of Wall Street in popular opinion is quite new, and I'm sure if you go back to the days of the Marlboro Cowboy when smoking represented freedom rather than lung cancer you could find similar surveys. (not to mention smoking in popular culture, the risks of smoking were not widely publicised until the 60s).
Whether big tech is comparable to big banks or big tobacco isn't really a question of popular opinion on big tech right now, but rather on the externalities they produce. The population being blind to externalities and negative effects of emerging industries is exceedingly common.
- sukilot 6y agoThe S&L crisis was 1986-1995. The demise in popular opinion is not new.
- smallnamespace 6y agoSavings and loans were not high finance outfits, they were mostly local, small banks that made bad bets.
- techbio 6y agoSource(s) for popular opinion across that date range?
- Anon4Now 6y agoI doubt you'd find much polling. The movies Wall Street (1987) and Other People's Money (1991) would be the next best thing for a pop culture view of the finance industry.
- techbio 6y agoSure, thanks, good points. Could also add Tom Wolfe's bestseller "Bonfire of the Vanities" to that time frame, and the Michael Lewis tell-all "Liar's Poker".
- Ericson2314 6y agoI heard finance was considered a sleepy boring backwater in the mid 20th century. Hardly any "positive reputation as brave risk takers".