6 ms·
The voluntary (not violently coerced) nature of transactions is an indispensable part of capitalism. Adam Smith emphasized this voluntary aspect in the Wealth o
by rayiner 6y ago
The voluntary (not violently coerced) nature of transactions is an indispensable part of capitalism. Adam Smith emphasized this voluntary aspect in the Wealth of Nations, which criticized Mercantilism.
This is like the game conservatives play where they say “considering race in solving problems is itself racist.” You can define terms however you want, but if you choose a definition that doesn’t actually match what other people are using, you’re engaged in demagoguery, not debate.
- jahaja 6y agoYes and those are wrong as well. One can not try to peddle "non-voluntary" as something exclusively directly violently coerced and ignore all the in-direct aspects of coercion set up by the same system. This does not constitute a voluntary exchange.
- rayiner 6y agoYour definition is a good one: the “voluntary exchange” in capitalism is narrow—it refers to exchange that is not “directly violently coerced.” Most people advocating capitalism would agree that this is what they mean by “voluntary exchange.” And you can make a perfectly good argument that this notion of what’s “voluntary” is inadequate. But in mercantilism and slavery, transactions are “directly violently coerced.” So they’re not examples of capitalism even by your own definition of what constitutes “voluntary. Put differently, when folks criticize capitalism for having an insufficient notion of “voluntary exchange” that only focuses on “violent coercion” (and there is a huge amount of literature on that) they’re acknowledging that capitalism excludes violent coercion. But then they turn around and apply the “capitalism” label to mercantilism and slavery, which are based on violent coercion!
- jahaja 6y agoMy point is not to broaden the definition of voluntary, but to emphasize that voluntary exchange itself has never been a crucial part of Capitalism. So both slavery and Imperialism can not be discarded from the incentive structure set up by Capitalism. Capitalism will simply exploit whatever there currently is to be exploited, without any ethics. The historical record, both past and present, is very clear on this.