4 ms·
By all means please do educate me on what I am not seeing. I once saw a British OS, Symbian, used around the world. I saw a Finnish company's phones used aroun
by lproven 6y ago
By all means please do educate me on what I am not seeing.
I once saw a British OS, Symbian, used around the world. I saw a Finnish company's phones used around the world. A little British computer maker designed what's still the most popular CPU architecture, ARM, but the company is long dead.
I understand many of the world's hard disks come from Thailand and Malaysia -- but from factories owned and run by Western Digital, Seagate, etc.
Yes, every country is part of the world market, but the salient point is who manages to break out of their own national market.
I am trying to think of Asian companies who make and sell computers or computer-related tech internationally. Samsung, Toshiba, Hitachi... But they run American OSes and use American designs.
Sony and Nintendo don't, but then they don't make CPUs or GPUs, do they? Sony's PCs run Windows, like the Japanese laptop vendors' do. When Sony made PDAs, they ran PalmOS; when Sanyo did, they ran Windows CE.
American dominance was not so universal just 25y ago. Can we identify what happened?
Is this all "worse is better"?
- esperent 6y ago> I understand many of the world's hard disks come from Thailand and Malaysia -- but from factories owned and run by Western Digital, Seagate, etc. And the largest manufacturer of screens, ram, and SSDs is Samsung. When it comes to smartphones, again, Samsung is top, then Huawei, and Apple is third. Laptops? It's Lenovo, a Hong Kong company. HP is second. Game consoles? Sony and Nintendo are top there, MS is third. (Edit: and CPUs, top is Arm, Japanese.) Saying these companies don't impact the world market is just plain wrong.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ExThermoGuy 6y agoI think his point is that they're all clones, or running American OS, or selling excellent quality commodities (in the sense that as a designer or engineer I don't care much about the part past its specs) Lenovo -> IBM Samsung + Huawei -> Google SSD, screens, ram -> commodity You might balk at SSDs being mere commodities (or screens for that matter). Surely Samsung SSDs and screens are better! Sure, and as a designer I might care. But I probably wouldn't, past the promised MTBF, viewing angle and contrast ratio. Put the SSD+display+CPU together and you get, for better or worse[1] , a largely American computing device. You don't get a BBC micro or an Acorn. Or a Setun. Nintendo is the only one who obviously stands out as different, making a unique computing device (albeit with an American CPU). Although even the N64 was largely an American design (SGI) [1] I think worse, in the sense that everything is a Unix monoculture.
- esperent 6y ago> You might balk at SSDs being mere commodities Why would I balk at that? SSDs, screens, RAM, CPUs, GPUs, laptops, phones, and are all commodities. I don't care about any of them past their specs and build quality. > Samsung + Huawei -> Google Oh come on. That's some serious reaching to prove your point right there.
- walterbell 6y agoNot in the slightest. Samsung tried to launch products that were rejected by Google via OEM licensing. Their commercial offerings are subject to external rules.
- esperent 6y agoEvery company's products are subject to external rules. All these huge companies constantly fight in court over trademarks, intellectual property, and so on. The products were not "rejected by Google", they were rejected by a court somewhere. And Google are at the receiving end of many such cases themselves, in many jurisdictions: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_vs._Google https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_vs._Google https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_v._Oracle_America https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_v._Oracle_America
- walterbell 6y agoSome products don't reach the stage of a public lawsuit, i.e. their fate is determined during private negotiations.
- zodiac 6y agoReally? I own a Huawei and AFAICT, the OS / services (eg the kernel, android, Google play services) are basically the same as what would run on eg a Google pixel.
- asveikau 6y ago>> > Samsung + Huawei -> Google > Oh come on. That's some serious reaching to prove your point right there. On the software front it's right on the mark though. Those devices wouldn't be much without Google. I know that Samsung in particular has had some other platforms (Bada? Tizen?) to try to break that dependency, but correct me if I'm wrong, I don't think it's been successful. AFAIK Google also has some kind of hardware requirements posed on the OEMs, so they influence hardware design this way.
- sct202 6y agoHe interestingly lists of DOS clones made in the UK by a US based company as an achievement in his blog post, but anything derivative from Asia or made by a multinational in Asia is not notable enough.
- asveikau 6y agoCertainly right now someone would be a fool to overlook Asian hardware companies, including examples you mentioned. But a bunch of this is more recent than the time period the article is discussing, as the comment you're replying to made some mention of.
- azinman2 6y agoSymbian was a terrible OS that was impossible to program for and needed to die. iOS rightly changed the entire paradigm, and they didn’t have the vision to catch up.