4 ms·
Is that something returning from Mars _orbit_, or returning samples from the surface?
by rsynnott 6y ago
Is that something returning from Mars _orbit_, or returning samples from the surface?
- Robotbeat 6y agoA SpaceX vehicle returning from the surface of Mars.
- raldi 6y agoYou're saying the vehicle will bring all the fuel needed for a return flight to Earth down to the surface of Mars and then back up again? Do you have a link with a description of how they're going to do this?
- Robotbeat 6y agoNo. It will make the fuel from Martian resources like water ice and the CO2 atmosphere. Using solar power. First to split the water to oxygen and hydrogen using electrolysis, then use the hydrogen with CO2 to make methane (& some water which is cycled back to the electrolysis step) using the Sabatier reaction. This is done on the International space Station today, by the way. The methane on ISS is simply vented (as the point on ISS is to recover the oxygen from the CO2, which is most of CO2’s mass). It takes a lot of energy, so there will need to be very large solar arrays on Mars, but it’s possible. This page describes the process: https://medium.com/spaceinmylifetime/how-spacex-will-refuel-on-the-surface-of-mars-3438bcc2aefe https://medium.com/spaceinmylifetime/how-spacex-will-refuel-...
- raldi 6y agoExactly. Returning from orbit is "easy", you just go into a free-return trajectory and don't even do much of a burn at Mars, if any at all. Getting a sample from the surface basically means you need to do a deceleration burn to get into orbit, and then the reverse after grabbing the sample (which itself must be accelerated to orbital speed). No small thing.
- Robotbeat 6y agoSpaceX isn’t planning to enter orbit around Mars but instead do direct entry.
- mLuby 6y agoA free-return trajectory doesn't enter orbit around a body, indeed its appeal is that if your propulsion fails while on such a course, you'll coast home "for free" rather than enter orbit around your target or drift into deep space. Entering orbit almost always requires an orbital insertion burn, and in the case of an Earth-Mars Hohmann transfer definitely does. Your point stands though: returning from a fly-by (including a free-return) requires much less fuel than returning from orbit, and even that's much easier than returning from the surface. For fun, take a look at rotovators (AKA "momentum exchange tethers") that could make orbital capture/departure—and even landing/launch—"free" on bodies with minimal atmosphere.
- raldi 6y agoCorrect, I misspoke: My first use of "orbit", I should have said "the area up around the planet, not down on the surface. The difference in difficulty (mainly, fuel requirements) between a flyby and an orbit is a crucial distinction often overlooked.