5 ms·
I am starting to think the interview is a waste of time. Sure, you want to make sure the person is more-or-less who they claim to be on the surface, but you wil
by bob1029 6y ago
I am starting to think the interview is a waste of time. Sure, you want to make sure the person is more-or-less who they claim to be on the surface, but you will never really understand their capability for reasoning with your problems until they are working in your process.
One of my earlier jobs dealing with code involved a very brief interview (no whiteboard involved) followed by a 6 month contract offer. The deal was that I basically had 6 months to prove myself, and if everyone felt like it was working out (myself included) this would be bumped into full-time with benefits. The crazy thing is, I was actually the one who decided I did not want to continue after the 6 months was out while they wanted me to stay very badly. I think this can be a really useful checkpoint tool for both sides.
Anyone can misrepresent themselves in an interview and dupe a room full of people for a day or 2. No one can keep up an act for 3-6 months continuously when working with complex code tasks. You will get found out before the term is up, assuming everyone is using this process as an evaluation tool and following up on it regularly.
- lowwave 6y agoYeah, there are so many times where I'm asked to solve some sudoku puzzle in an interview. It is really sign of a big interview question.
- drglitch 6y agoArrangements like this are much harder in US because 1) by default there is no health insurance if you’re a contractor, and obtaining your own is incredibly expensive and 2) there are also pretty complex tax implications of being a contractor; there are many other factors as well. It also puts a candidate at a disadvantage, because looking for a job is heavily one-sided burden. On a personal level, as both (occasionally) a candidate and a senior hiring manager, I always wonder about white boarding - i believe it works when the interviewer is looking for your thought process, and not code specifically. For example, something as simple as saying “I don’t expect this code to compile” at beginning of interview immediately puts candidate at ease and let’s you understand their logic and not the ability to recall specific function signatures on the fly.
- zerr 6y agoWell, terminating an employement is as well quite easy in US, regardless who initiates it - employer or employee.
- seneca 6y agoIt is easy to terminate straight white men under 40. Anyone else is extremely difficult anywhere with an HR department. Protected classes are taken very seriously.
- ssully 6y agoI had a similar arrangement like this in the U.S. but it was for 1 year. When applying for the position it was listed as a term appointment and they were up front about the arrangement (same as OP; after a year, if everyone is happy, the term appointment becomes a FTE). The term position had all the same benefits as a FTE, it just had the time cap on it.
- zeku 6y agoMy company does this as policy, except we hire them and put them on full benefits. However there is a 6 month period where you can be fired a lot easier than after that 6 months. It seems like a reasonable compromise that doesn't leave the job seeker without health insurance etc.
- usefulcat 6y agoI've seen this done before. As others pointed out, the lack of health insurance can be a problem in the U.S., although sometimes can be mitigated if the candidate still has access via COBRA. Even considering the flaws, I think this approach is better than immediately hiring someone full time. I've seen some candidates who seemed perfect on paper and fine in interviews and then turned out to be utterly toxic to actually work with. For the interviewee, the chances of encountering that situation are even greater, since there is one interviewee but typically many future coworkers. Some personality traits can be very difficult to surface in an interview environment. IMO interviews are worthless for getting that kind of information.
- twic 6y ago> The deal was that I basically had 6 months to prove myself, and if everyone felt like it was working out (myself included) this would be bumped into full-time with benefits. In the UK, we sort of have this in the form of probation - in most permanent jobs, you don't gain full employment rights until you've done a probationary period, which is usually six months. You get full salary and benefits during that period, but you can be fired with no notice at any time (or something like that). In practice, though, the culture is not to use the probationary period as an extended interview, but more of a backstop against really screwing up hiring. You'd only let someone go after probation if they turned out to be absolutely incompetent or unsuitable, not if they were just disappointing. It would be interesting to try using probation differently, though. Make the interview more of a screen, employ twice as many people as you need, only retain half of them at the end of probation, and be explicit throughout that this is the plan. I suspect you could implement and communicate this such that it wasn't absolutely horrible for probationers - active and transparent review during probation, one or two months' golden parachute, what else?
- ubercow13 6y agoIf you got 2-3 of those failed probationary periods on your CV though, you'd be stuffed. But that's probably a good thing.
- braythwayt 6y agoIn Ontario, the letter of the law says you can be fired during probation for any or no reason (modulo human rights legislation), but in practice an employer can still be sued for wrongful dismissal if the employer terminates an employee without demonstrating cause. It’s best to have experienced employment law advice when devising any scheme around using probation as a kind of hiring scheme, as opposed to as a last resort if things go very badly. I will not give legal advice, but for example I would be very careful before implementing a “Survivor: Tech Island” scheme where the company hires more people than it genuinely expects to keep following their probationary period. I have been told that if I hire someone I think is questionable with the thought that “if it doesn’t work out, we’ll just let them go during probation,” that can backfire as I make a conscious choice to hire them despite my reservations. Again, INAL, but I would tread carefully around using probation for winnowing candidates out.
- gfxgirl 6y agoIn 2012 I was told Google gets 1 million applications a year. How do you decide which 1000 of those get 6 month contract offer? How many millions of dollars in lost productivity are you willing to lose of the people who don't pass your 6 month test that you had wasting space, taking up training time, having people have to review and reject their code, etc? What will those people do who gave up their lives somewhere else to be part of your company do when you tell them you've decided to not make them employee when their contract is up?
- jeffe 6y agoThe value is similar to that of internships - the amortized cost of a 6 month 'trial period' should be similar if not cheaper than false positives that are a lot tougher to fire so you avoid dumpster fires like Amazon's mandatory attrition rate. I also wouldn't call it giving up there lives, when they know what they're signing up for and are presumably getting paid a similar amount to the the full time role they're applying for. Now if FAANG companies try to use their reputation to get cheap labor with no intention of hiring I don't have answers to that, but I can't imagine it would be worth the cost.
- gfxgirl 6y agoThey still have some selection criteria for internships. It's not like they take the first 100 students at random so you're left with the same issue. You have to narrow the selection. That likely includes interviews.
- braythwayt 6y agoWe already have this extended trial period in tech, it’s called an internship, and responsible companies pay interns. Some internships come through university co-op programs, some through organizations that set this up for people following non-traditional career paths, and some companies “roll their own.” But these positions are overwhelmingly for people breaking into the field. They have much to gain, and very little to lose by working for a company for three months with an uncertain expectation of a full-time job. Now consider hiring an experienced worker who is out of a job. If Alice offers them a contract with the company having an option to turn it into full-time, while Bob offers them full-time work with the understanding that a major screw-up would lead to dismissal during a probationary period, Bob’s offer is much lower risk. Finally, consider an experienced worker with a job. For a non-hypothetical example, they’re working at a famous name, with options, and a YC startup that has grown to 200 employEes recruits them. It’s going to be very difficult to get them to walk away from guaranteed employment that feeds their children, for a temporary gig with no equity participation And the understanding that it’s an extended job interview. —- The above focuses on the candidate’s risk/reward calculation. What about the company? Well, the least experienced person has the greatest uncertainty. They might be very smart, but unable to work well with people. How would we know without giving them temporary work with people? The most experienced person has the least overall uncertainty. They “brought the receipts.” Without arguing about how they should be interviewed/tested, if they aren’t a completely toxic person, if they have a non-fatal weakness that pops up, it can probably be managed to be fixed, or accommodated. The employer’s risk goes down as the candidate’s experience goes up. Sure, it would be a bed of roses if the company could hire senior people on a one-year contract and see how all the intangibles work out, but that usually isn’t necessary, and it’s not going to happen often enough to operationalize that as part of the process. —- TL;DR: There is no one-size-fits-all approach that fits all levels of experience, and also scales to large numbers of hires, and also is repeatable. But the kernel of what you suggest works well for the sweet-spot of high-uncertainty and low risk to the candidate.