3 ms·
> What we understand as “capitalism” (free market economies based on voluntary transactions) is incompatible with imperialism That sounds like a No True Scotsm
by triceratops 6y ago
> What we understand as “capitalism” (free market economies based on voluntary transactions) is incompatible with imperialism
That sounds like a No True Scotsman fallacy. "It's not voluntary? By jove, then it's not capitalism!" Is every person in a market economy that hates their job and does it solely for food, shelter, and clothing, living under not-capitalism? How "voluntary" does a transaction have to be, exactly?
Mercantilism was proto-capitalism. It had all the features - "property rights, capital accumulation, wage labor, voluntary exchange, a price system and competitive markets." - on a smaller scale. Wikipedia mentions it as an earlier form of capitalism[1]. British merchants and industry still enjoyed the benefits of the free market - within the empire - but Indians and other subjects did not. And when Britain made a pivot to free trade in the 1840s[2], they still didn't let India participate. And even capitalist economies have trade barriers or tariffs today. Other than the focus on gold and balance of trade and payments, there isn't that much of a hard-line between capitalism and mercantilism. They're on the same spectrum.
Belgian colonization of the Congo and the rubber farm atrocities happened in the late 19th-early 20th century[3] when Belgium was pretty well capitalist, not mercantilist. Blood diamonds were/are traded in modern capitalist systems.[4] The participation of every actor in the chain of capitalism is successively less and less "voluntary". In some markets and industries, things are pretty good for everyone and even the person on the lowest rung does pretty well. In others...it's not so great.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Mercantile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Mercantile
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Industrial_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Industrial_Revoluti...
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocities_in_the_Congo_Free_State https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocities_in_the_Congo_Free_S...
4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_diamond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_diamond
- rayiner 6y ago> That sounds like a No True Scotsman fallacy. "It's not voluntary? By jove, then it's not capitalism!" The Wikipedia article you link to contradicts your premise: > Capitalism is an economic system based on the private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit.[1][2][3][4] Central characteristics of capitalism include private property and the recognition of property rights, capital accumulation, wage labor, voluntary exchange, a price system and competitive markets It’s one thing to complain about imperfect implementations of capitalism. For example, observing that economic duress makes some labor transactions only nominally voluntary. But voluntary exchange is a definitional aspect of capitalism. It’s the underlying assumption behind much of the economic theory of capitalism. Criticizing capitalism by pointing to mercantilism and slavery—which are based on precisely the opposite of voluntary exchange—is nothing more than a rhetorical slight of hand.
- triceratops 6y agoMercantilism had "recognition of property rights, capital accumulation, wage labor, voluntary exchange, a price system and competitive markets" too; just not for all the actors. That's why I called it "proto-capitalism". What about when violent coercion happens under a capitalist system, like with Belgium and Congo, or blood diamonds? That makes it suddenly "not-capitalism"? You might be technically correct but it's semantic handwashing. If those atrocities due to the incentives in a capitalist system, it's entirely fair to pin them on capitalism. Otherwise it's no different than communism apologists claiming true communism has never been tried and therefore, things like the Holodomor shouldn't count against it - which is equally bad.
- rayiner 6y ago> What about when violent coercion happens under a capitalist system, like with Belgium and Congo, or blood diamonds? That makes it suddenly "not-capitalism"? Are those things happening “under a capitalist system?” It seems to me like a situation where companies have to leave a capitalist country (Belgium) to take advantage of people in a country that doesn’t have a capitalist system and didn’t protect property rights and the voluntariness if exchange (the Congo). Is the Belgian Congo a manifestation of capitalism? By the same token, could you say it’s a manifestation of “parliamentary democracy?” I don’t think either makes sense, because the whole point is that capitalism/parliamentary Democracy aren’t operative in the Congo. > You might be technically correct but it's semantic handwashing. If those atrocities due to the incentives in a capitalist system, it's entirely fair to pin them on capitalism. “People want to steal other people’s resources and labor” is an incentive that exists in every system. It’s not unique to capitalism. Non-capitalist nations have been invading places and taking their resources for millennia. > Otherwise it's no different than communism apologists claiming true communism has never been tried and therefore, things like the Holodomor shouldn't count against it - which is equally bad. The Holdomor was a famine that was the result of a failure of central planning, which is a logical part of communism. Similarly, you could fairly blame say income inequality on capitalism. Or sweatshop labor, or unsafe workplaces. But Belgian Congo is more like the Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan. That’s not a failure of communism just because a communist state was involved.