2 ms·
My partner did EFL for years. She always said that truth lies both sides of the whole-word vs phonics debate. Here in Queensland Australia it was deeply politi
by ggm 6y ago
My partner did EFL for years. She always said that truth lies both sides of the whole-word vs phonics debate.
Here in Queensland Australia it was deeply politicised in a left right electoral battle between state governments, teaching unions, public and privately funded schools.
As an EFL teacher her praxis was focussed on adults not pre-literate children which is an important distinction.
That said, I like this nutshell exemplifier of the problem.
"Cat" c-a-t. Cee aaye tee spells cat.
Now do that for "women" (UK english, Australian english typically pronounced "wimmin")
- pastage 6y agoEnglish sucks, the phonic rules are all over the place but; Is women the only word you do pronounce according to those rules, would you understand me if I said "women"? A key concept is having a reading buddy that can listen to you and try to understand. I would say that the more frequent the word the more likely it is that the pronounciation is a tad different from spelling.
- ggm 6y agoAx me that in another century