3 ms·
The triangle in this is the worst bit of communication of quantitative information that I've seen lately. No one show it to Tufte.
by mlyle 6y ago
The triangle in this is the worst bit of communication of quantitative information that I've seen lately. No one show it to Tufte.
- RobLach 6y agoNo joke. How was this better than a bar chart like how every performance metric comparison ever uses. And that 2 points are “more is better” while one is “less is better” is inexcusable.
- kanobo 6y agoI'll like to know why there's a Koala behind the triangle!
- p1mrx 6y agoIt's basically a spider chart, but setting the new version (rather than the old) to 100% makes it especially confusing.
- duskwuff 6y agoUsing a radar chart for just three pairs of data points is pretty inexcusable, too. It's not a great style of chart in general, but at least it makes some sense when there's more like ten or fifteen comparisons involved.
- jnwatson 6y agoAlso, the axes have opposite "good" directions, so the size of the triangle means nothing.
- microcolonel 6y agoIt's particularly confusing because of the mixed scales; two negative characteristics mixed with a positive characteristic. I was reading it initially as “while we regressed on power and area, we got a lot of performance out of that!”. I think that ultimately it achieved its goal, by being extra suspicious and wrong, and inviting you to look at it for long periods of time. Cute koala clip art too, I can sorta guess where in the office that would have come from, if they were at the office.
- Avshalom 6y agoI like how one of the metrics is Area causing me to try to compare the area of the two triangles.