4 ms·
> I love capitalism. It's the best of all the available systems, because it's the most conducive to personal liberty. But let's not pretend it doesn't have a lo
by rayiner 6y ago
> I love capitalism. It's the best of all the available systems, because it's the most conducive to personal liberty. But let's not pretend it doesn't have a long, shared history with imperialism.
It doesn’t! What we understand as “capitalism” (free market economies based on voluntary transactions) is incompatible with imperialism. Britain used its military power to ensure that India would sell commodities to Britain while buying finished goods back from Britain. That’s not capitalism. We had a perfectly good word for it when I was in K-12: mercantilism.
We have different words for mercantilism and capitalism because they’re different. You know they’re different because people decry the WTO as a destructive capitalist vehicle for facilitating exactly the thing (free trade) that mercantilism prohibited.
Words matter! Definitions matter! There are things you can fairly pin on unregulated capitalism. For example, the requirement that transactions be voluntary doesn’t rule out child labor (in many but not all cases), below minimum wage labor, or labor in unsafe workplaces, insofar as all are voluntary. But it does rule out slavery, which isn’t a voluntary transaction. It also rules out mercantilism, which isn’t based on voluntary free trade, and Belgian rubber farms, which weren’t based on free exchange either of labor or of resources.
Sure, you can redefine “capitalism” to make “something other than what people today understand as capitalism” but you can play stupid semantic games like that with anything.
- joshuamorton 6y agoBritain maintained it's imperialist reach well into the "capitalist" age (into the 20th century!). The US maintains limited imperialism to this day, although less so than in the Cold War era. If you're going to argue that capitalism is incompatible with imperialism, then sure you can be pedantically correct, but then you're arguing about capitalism as a macro-economic policy and not a micro-economic policy, in which case capitalism has nothing to do with personal liberty whatsoever, it has to do with tariffs (and we still aren't doing a good job of it). That's not usually an interesting discussion to have. And if you're going to make that argument, you sort of also have to accept that Socialism has never been tried (and that it might result in greater personal liberty).
- rayiner 6y agoCapitalist economies can invade other countries and take their resources just like socialist economies can. That doesn’t say anything about those economic systems.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI agree, but you appeared to cla that capitalist economics were incompatible with imperialism by definition and that any such economy would really he mercantilist. You seem to have changed your mind. There original statement was (I believe) that capitalisrlt economies have a history of imposing imperialism on other nations. Do you agree with that, or not?
- rayiner 6y ago> There original statement was (I believe) that capitalisrlt economies have a history of imposing imperialism on other nations. Do you agree with that, or not? I agree with that. But that’s not how I read the OP’s statement, and not how the links between capitalism and imperialism are developed in the relevant literature. That appeared to go further to imply that imperialism is itself a manifestation of capitalism, rather than something that’s simply compatible with capitalism. It’s the difference between saying that Democratic countries have a history of imperialism (Britain, Rome) and saying that imperialism is a manifestation of or structurally linked to democracy.
- triceratops 6y ago> What we understand as “capitalism” (free market economies based on voluntary transactions) is incompatible with imperialism That sounds like a No True Scotsman fallacy. "It's not voluntary? By jove, then it's not capitalism!" Is every person in a market economy that hates their job and does it solely for food, shelter, and clothing, living under not-capitalism? How "voluntary" does a transaction have to be, exactly? Mercantilism was proto-capitalism. It had all the features - "property rights, capital accumulation, wage labor, voluntary exchange, a price system and competitive markets." - on a smaller scale. Wikipedia mentions it as an earlier form of capitalism[1]. British merchants and industry still enjoyed the benefits of the free market - within the empire - but Indians and other subjects did not. And when Britain made a pivot to free trade in the 1840s[2], they still didn't let India participate. And even capitalist economies have trade barriers or tariffs today. Other than the focus on gold and balance of trade and payments, there isn't that much of a hard-line between capitalism and mercantilism. They're on the same spectrum. Belgian colonization of the Congo and the rubber farm atrocities happened in the late 19th-early 20th century[3] when Belgium was pretty well capitalist, not mercantilist. Blood diamonds were/are traded in modern capitalist systems.[4] The participation of every actor in the chain of capitalism is successively less and less "voluntary". In some markets and industries, things are pretty good for everyone and even the person on the lowest rung does pretty well. In others...it's not so great. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Mercantile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Mercantile 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Industrial_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Industrial_Revoluti... 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocities_in_the_Congo_Free_State https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocities_in_the_Congo_Free_S... 4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_diamond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_diamond
- rayiner 6y ago> That sounds like a No True Scotsman fallacy. "It's not voluntary? By jove, then it's not capitalism!" The Wikipedia article you link to contradicts your premise: > Capitalism is an economic system based on the private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit.[1][2][3][4] Central characteristics of capitalism include private property and the recognition of property rights, capital accumulation, wage labor, voluntary exchange, a price system and competitive markets It’s one thing to complain about imperfect implementations of capitalism. For example, observing that economic duress makes some labor transactions only nominally voluntary. But voluntary exchange is a definitional aspect of capitalism. It’s the underlying assumption behind much of the economic theory of capitalism. Criticizing capitalism by pointing to mercantilism and slavery—which are based on precisely the opposite of voluntary exchange—is nothing more than a rhetorical slight of hand.
- jahaja 6y agoThis is just ahistorical garbage. Capitalism is responsible for the incentive structure it set up. Capitalism didn't suddenly spring up after WW2. Stop trying to surgically remove inconvenient facts from Capitalism. Voluntary transaction has never been at the heart of Capitalism, nor has it ever been a per-requisite, and it is still not the case. To call the choice of the propertyless of accepting a "transaction" or starvation as voluntary is just manipulative language. > transactions be voluntary doesn’t rule out child labor (in many but not all cases), below minimum wage labor, or labor in unsafe workplaces, insofar as all are voluntary. How can you write that this sounds like it is a voluntary transaction with a straight face? Free people doesn't voluntary accept those conditions.
- rayiner 6y agoThe voluntary (not violently coerced) nature of transactions is an indispensable part of capitalism. Adam Smith emphasized this voluntary aspect in the Wealth of Nations, which criticized Mercantilism. This is like the game conservatives play where they say “considering race in solving problems is itself racist.” You can define terms however you want, but if you choose a definition that doesn’t actually match what other people are using, you’re engaged in demagoguery, not debate.
- jahaja 6y agoYes and those are wrong as well. One can not try to peddle "non-voluntary" as something exclusively directly violently coerced and ignore all the in-direct aspects of coercion set up by the same system. This does not constitute a voluntary exchange.
- rayiner 6y agoYour definition is a good one: the “voluntary exchange” in capitalism is narrow—it refers to exchange that is not “directly violently coerced.” Most people advocating capitalism would agree that this is what they mean by “voluntary exchange.” And you can make a perfectly good argument that this notion of what’s “voluntary” is inadequate. But in mercantilism and slavery, transactions are “directly violently coerced.” So they’re not examples of capitalism even by your own definition of what constitutes “voluntary. Put differently, when folks criticize capitalism for having an insufficient notion of “voluntary exchange” that only focuses on “violent coercion” (and there is a huge amount of literature on that) they’re acknowledging that capitalism excludes violent coercion. But then they turn around and apply the “capitalism” label to mercantilism and slavery, which are based on violent coercion!