5 ms·
> We used to value self-reliance and risk taking, but a growing chunk of America now wants a more risk-averse government-reliant (in the form of guaranteed pens
by rayiner 6y ago
> We used to value self-reliance and risk taking, but a growing chunk of America now wants a more risk-averse government-reliant (in the form of guaranteed pensions, etc) European style society.
I’d be happy if that’s all they wanted. Some people want to “dismantl[e] White Supremacy, Patriarchy, Capitalism, Imperialism and the role the state plays in supporting them.” And instead of saying “hey, one of those things is not like the other” I now drive past a street in DC every day named after an organization that has this quote on their DC chapter’s front page. (Technically, it’s an honorary name, but DC streets have proper street signs for those.) Meanwhile, the Smithsonian is publishing materials condemning “objective, rational linear thinking” and “progress” and “competition.”
I get that these are fringe academic ideas that fringe people have injected into an otherwise really important conversation. But I’m pretty alarmed about the degree to which mainstream sources are implicitly sanctioning these kinds of assertions. Silicon Valley as we know it can’t exist within this intellectual framework.
- tehjoker 6y agoThey're all deeply interconnected. Read a book. All of those systems involve hierarchies that are more or less flexible. Capitalism has been highly productive as an economic system, but it still is deeply undemocratic and could safely be called tyrannical as it has few if any democratic features below the level of the wealthy shareholders. EDIT: In the case of many of our tech giant friends, the trend in the mid-2000s to late 2010s was to create different tiers of stock so that the founders would have near absolute authority over the company. This is like a private monarchy and is even more authoritarian than the previous generation of companies. EDIT2: The funny thing is, because we distrusted the financial system so thoroughly in the early 2000s, cutting out the influence of institutional finance was seen as liberating while in actuality we were merely constructing an even more hierarchical and conservative system.
- rayiner 6y ago> They're all deeply interconnected. Read a book. I don’t really enjoy fiction books.
- triceratops 6y agoI love capitalism. It's the best of all the available systems, because it's the most conducive to personal liberty. But let's not pretend it doesn't have a long, shared history with imperialism. India, the jewel in the British crown, was originally conquered by a private corporation. Ditto for Indonesia and the Dutch. Capitalism's other greatest hits include the transatlantic slave trade, Belgian rubber farms in Congo, blood diamonds, and modern factory farming. Sure it was great for Europeans to have cheap sugar from the Caribbean, and the traders and planters became very prosperous. But at what cost? Capitalism needs laws, regulations, and guardrails. Capitalism didn't voluntarily renounce slavery, or child labor. It didn't provide worker safety protections or overtime or other important labor protections. It would never have done, left to its own devices. It required "intrusive government regulation" and activism.
- rayiner 6y ago> I love capitalism. It's the best of all the available systems, because it's the most conducive to personal liberty. But let's not pretend it doesn't have a long, shared history with imperialism. It doesn’t! What we understand as “capitalism” (free market economies based on voluntary transactions) is incompatible with imperialism. Britain used its military power to ensure that India would sell commodities to Britain while buying finished goods back from Britain. That’s not capitalism. We had a perfectly good word for it when I was in K-12: mercantilism. We have different words for mercantilism and capitalism because they’re different. You know they’re different because people decry the WTO as a destructive capitalist vehicle for facilitating exactly the thing (free trade) that mercantilism prohibited. Words matter! Definitions matter! There are things you can fairly pin on unregulated capitalism. For example, the requirement that transactions be voluntary doesn’t rule out child labor (in many but not all cases), below minimum wage labor, or labor in unsafe workplaces, insofar as all are voluntary. But it does rule out slavery, which isn’t a voluntary transaction. It also rules out mercantilism, which isn’t based on voluntary free trade, and Belgian rubber farms, which weren’t based on free exchange either of labor or of resources. Sure, you can redefine “capitalism” to make “something other than what people today understand as capitalism” but you can play stupid semantic games like that with anything.
- 6y ago
- ottomanbob 6y agoThe road to hell is named with good intentions.
- tptacek 6y agoWhy are you alarmed by this, when all the available evidence suggests that the mainstream of America is receptive to the obvious parts of these ideas ("stop killing unarmed black people") and not at all receptive to the rest ("seize the means of production")? Look at who won the nomination.
- rayiner 6y agoI mean that’s fair. To calm myself down I listen to Keisha Lance Bottoms talk about public private partnerships. But, I do need that talking down because: 1) I don’t trust academics and I think they have outsized influence on culture. I think, for example, academics destroyed the original understanding of the Establishment Clause, and thereby hastened the decline of organized religion as one of the institutions of civil society. I think that is a bad thing. I worry about what’s next on the chopping block. For example, while I don’t think the government is going to seize the means of production, I worry “life, liberty, and property” doesn’t have the cachet it used to. Many people don’t really believe the constitution protects economic rights. 2) Related to (1), I’m worried some well-meaning teacher will tell my brown daughter that “rational linear thinking” is “white culture.” (That would result in a lawsuit.) 3) I know few people my age and economic/educational class who actually wanted Biden to win. The “wonk” set seems to be much more amenable to these fringe ideas. And because we’ve sanctioned an unconstitutional administrative state where unelected wonks wield great power, I worry. 4) There is a disconnect between what I consider mainstream sources out of historical inertia, and maybe what they are now. I have a hard time reading the NYT these days. But I also recognize that, due to massive declines in readership, the NYT is more of a niche source than it used to be. But who still reads it? See (3).
- tptacek 6y agoBy all the accounts I've read, what we're looking at right now is nothing even close to the Long Hot Summer. You'd have to know where to look to find evidence of protests in Chicago. It's tough to metabolize not knowing anyone who wanted Biden to win, because he won the primary overwhelmingly; compare the map in Michigan in 2016 to 2020. Biden won Washtenaw County! Single-payer health care polls well in the abstract, but failed as an actual ballot measure in Colorado and Vermont; people support all sorts of things in the abstract, but in reality don't support radical change. I have the same contempt you do for the "rational linear thinking" thing and haven't shut up about it for weeks. But then, the Black History Museum took down the poster; it looks like it survived as long as it did because nobody was paying attention to it. Both The New York Times and the Washington Post ran reviews tearing down _White Fragility_; when people actually read the book, rather than nodding their head to the title (it's a great title! admit it!), the scales from their eyes. If anything, I think the most reasonable concern is that we won't change enough. The police violence and accountability problem is very real and very serious.