6 ms·
Looking at stories like this, you need to realize how far out of the running this technology is. The power density of ITER (gross fusion power of the reactor d
by pfdietz 6y ago
Looking at stories like this, you need to realize how far out of the running this technology is.
The power density of ITER (gross fusion power of the reactor divided by the volume of the reactor, not just the volume of the plasma) is 50 kW/m^3. This is horribly low, about 1/400th the power density of a PWR reactor vessel.
The power/$ is also horribly bad. The cost is going to have to come down by two orders of magnitude to start being competitive.
Fusion is an example of sunk cost thinking. The only reason we're working on it is because we had been. A clean sheet energy strategy would put very little resources into fusion.
- willis936 6y agoYou don’t speak for the people working on it, so your claim of sunk cost fallacy is null.
- pfdietz 6y agoI am allowed to form my own opinion from the evidence we have. The evidence is that fusion is a huge boondoggle that is extremely unlikely to deliver anything useful. Asking people working in a field if it's promising is silly, since they are a biased sample. If they didn't think it was promising, they likely wouldn't be working in the field.
- willis936 6y agoIndeed you are allowed to come to your own conclusions. I object to this statement. >Fusion is an example of sunk cost thinking. The only reason we're working on it is because we had been. This is putting forward the opinions of others. The premise is the people who stay in the field lacked some form of awareness of your arguments. They are aware and they disagree. You can’t assume your argument is accepted in the argument.
- pfdietz 6y agoNo, I'm sure the people in the field are, at some level, well aware of the arguments. They're not new, after all -- look at Lidsky from 1983. But the human power of rationalization is very powerful when your career depends on it. They get a comforting assurance that the argument was wrong, and they don't look too closely to see if the refutation was actually correct. What did Upton Sinclair say? "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
- willis936 6y agoIf the arguments are old, how is that a point in favor of people in the field being unaware of them? There has been 50 years of people arguing against the use of resources in pursuit of this field. You still think people in a field of physics have somehow sheltered themselves from these arguments? You have had a conversation with a physicist, yes? They will shred someone making dubious claims. Further, if you think plasma physicists would go hungry if fusion research ceased, you’re simply wrong. Nobody researches fusion for the paycheck. An industry paycheck for the equivalent quality of work is double.
- pfdietz 6y ago> how is that a point in favor of people in the field being unaware of them? Perhaps they are movtivated readers and deliberately don't read the argument for comprehension. Kind of like what you just did there.
- lambdatronics 6y agoSolar was 2 orders of magnitude out of the running around 1975 -- and now it's at grid parity. So maybe fusion is 45 years away? :P You're right that the cost is going to have to come down, and the power density up, before fusion can compete. High-field superconductors are one obvious route, and using plasma configurations that make better use of the magnetic fields are another. Either one of those approaches could deliver about two orders of magnitude in power density -- and they could be combined. >The only reason we're working on it is because we had been. I think there's been an element of that in the way the federal program has been run, but claiming it's the only reason to pursue fusion is not defensible.
- pfdietz 6y agoThat approach doesn't work, because reactor power density becomes limited by wall loading (neutron and/or thermal), regardless of how good the plasma physics is. It's the square cube law. At a given wall loading limit the volumetric power density is inversely proportional to the linear dimensions. And a DT fusion reactor must be meters across, due to the fixed cross section of the neutrons with wall materials. In contrast, fission fuel rods are 1 cm in diameter and are closely spaced, so the available surface area for heat transfer is much higher (neutrons in fission are also much less of a problem, since they carry a much smaller fraction of the energy output and are of much lower energy, on average.) (I think the only hope for DT fusion is something like LINUS, where the entire first wall is thick flowing liquid lithium.) > I think there's been an element of that in the way the federal program has been run, but claiming it's the only reason to pursue fusion is not defensible. What is the other reason? I cannot find any other plausible justification. This is particularly true now that fission is out of the running. Fusion used to be justified by "it won't be too much more expensive than fission, but it's safer and won't run out of uranium." That argument is now pointless.
- lambdatronics 6y ago>the entire first wall is thick flowing liquid lithium Yeah, I agree on the liquid walls. I think the optimum might be to have a thin Li first surface flow that is relatively cool, then a shell of SiC, and behind it a PbLi breeding blanket that can be at higher temperature. There's a trade-off because the first-surface can't be made too hot or the evaporation will pollute the plasma, but getting high thermodynamic efficiency means using higher coolant temperature. The thickness of the liquid first-surface plays into the lifetime of the SiC shell -- more shielding in front of it means longer life (so lower maintenance costs & higher reactor up-time, and less radwaste), but lower thermal conversion efficiency on average. There are problems of course -- corrosion by Li, splashing of droplets into the plasma, MHD drag & pump power requirements, incompatibility of lithium with many forms of sensors & actuators for plasma control.... (OTOH, most sensors and actuators can't tolerate radiation anyway, so fancy control techniques just don't stand a chance in a reactor anyway. We need boring, stable plasma configurations that just sit there and work.) >What is the other reason? Some people think they can make a fortune :D