3 ms·
In my experience in teaching English as a foreign language to students of all abilities and levels... you quickly discover that different strategies work for di
by crazygringo 6y ago
In my experience in teaching English as a foreign language to students of all abilities and levels... you quickly discover that different strategies work for different students.
Some students are strong with vocab, others with grammar. Some with listening, others with speaking. Some with oral, some with written. I could go on and on with 20 other different things.
Education experts do attempt to identify and refine the methods that prove to work best, but real-world teachers know that those methods come in waves, fads of academia, and that a teacher needs to know the basics of all methods, combined with the strengths and weaknesses of their students, and use their intuition to try to come up with a good combination.
So it's less about a "balanced" approach, and more of a "try everything and see what sticks with any individual student" approach.
Because here's what does work: let students build core competency around wherever their natural strengths are, and then they'll eventually get the other stuff.
But the idea that "certain methods will outperform others" is grossly simplistic. Sure there are some dumb methods that don't work for anybody but those get quickly discarded. Of the rest, even if a method outperforms in the aggregate, it's going to be terribly underperforming for a significant proportion of students.
- DangitBobby 6y agoDon't you believe that it's also possible that there are sometimes methods that do outperform all others in the long term for everyone (such as phonics) but can initially be harder than other ways (such as three-cueing)? So all _you_ see as a teacher in the little time you get with a pupil who doesn't learn as well is that the phonics isn't "working for them" and that three-cueing is "just how this person learns," but really you're just teaching them an inferior shortcut which leads to worse outcomes.
- watwut 6y agoIf you learned to read and continued to read few years later, it does not matter what method you used initially. After few years you are remembering how most common words look like and instantly "know" them.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIf you don't have skills to aquire new words, you may get thru elementary but have a very hard time in hs and uni.
- insickness 6y agoThis is exactly the point that the article is trying to dispel. If you learn to read in an improper way, such as 3-cue, you could carry that with you and struggle all your life.
- crazygringo 6y agoNope, I don't believe so. In the long term we're all dead, and students need to be learning and staying motivated every day. Remember, phonics gives immediate improvements too, for short words. So it's pretty much a false dichotomy. For students who are picking up phonics quickly from the start, great. For the students who are struggling from the start, try other methods ASAP. As a teacher, figuring out which methods work for a student isn't rocket science. Your students are either getting better on a visible daily basis or not. We're not talking a 5% difference in outcomes, it's more like 75% difference. (Of course, bad teachers just don't pay attention at all, or are too swamped with work to be able to.)
- pastage 6y agoThe article states 40% of pupils will learn to read efficiently no matter what, it is going to be hard to identify those methods that do not work for anybody. Further we have talked about local maximum in the comments here, the brain is lazy so some methods will hurt your ability to learn. On the flip side I agree that only doing phonics might be a local maximum for the group.