3 ms·
> Now they have flipped that to drive students into in demand careers, as there is a shortage. If those careers were in-demand, shouldn't the wages on offer be
by triceratops 6y ago
> Now they have flipped that to drive students into in demand careers, as there is a shortage.
If those careers were in-demand, shouldn't the wages on offer be enough to drive students into those careers?
- pb7 6y agoYou’re giving 18 year olds too much credit. Ask the average college student what job they’re planning on getting with their degree and how much it pays and they won’t be able to tell you.
- dasudasu 6y agoAs an easy counter-example, there was a decent drop in people getting CS degrees following the dot-com bubble implosion and pervasive rumors of offshoring thereafter. Correspondingly, there was an uptick while the bubble was forming.
- triceratops 6y agoCollege students may not know precise numbers. But they're sharp enough to work out "barista with an art degree" makes less than "banker with a finance degree". And if they don't already know "art degree = low-paying career" we're failing them before they ever reach college.
- true_religion 6y agoA lot of people think art degrees will pay well because they see the explosion of interest in anime, web illustrations, comics, and graphic novels. They don’t see the supply side though, so they assume good demand means a good career path.
- tzs 6y agoNot necessarily. There are at least two reasons more money might not be sufficient for many students. First, just because a career is high demand, high pay now doesn't mean it still will be in a few years. Enough people might go into it chasing the money to turn the shortage into a surplus. Second, it can be hard to change careers later, especially careers that require a degree. Many will prefer to pick a career they are confident they will be happy with for the rest of the working life, even if that won't make as much money.
- triceratops 6y agoI think you're making my points for me. > First, just because a career is high demand, high pay now doesn't mean it still will be in a few years. Enough people might go into it chasing the money to turn the shortage into a surplus. Sounds like a subsidy for the industries that hire those workers. High wages are good for workers. Why champion policies that would cost taxpayer money while lowering wages? > Many will prefer to pick a career they are confident they will be happy with for the rest of the working life, even if that won't make as much money. Correct. Which is why a degree of less certain market value should cost less - both to the payer, but also for the educating institution. I don't understand why art degrees should cost anywhere in the same ballpark as engineering degrees when you consider the cost differences in capital and labor inputs (labs and equipment vs art studios and supplies, engineers vs artists) and their eventual respective market values. Liberal and fine arts people (should) cost less to educate and they make less money. Ergo they should have to pay less to be educated.
- redis_mlc 6y agoIn countries like Australia and Canada, employers won't raise salaries "on principal."