4 ms·
It's actually idiotic and anti-market. If art history majors get low-paying jobs, it makes no sense to have their degrees cost more. They should actually be inc
by triceratops 6y ago
It's actually idiotic and anti-market. If art history majors get low-paying jobs, it makes no sense to have their degrees cost more. They should actually be increasing cost of the high-paying majors and reducing the cost of the low-paying majors, in order to correctly reflect the market value of those degrees.
- throwaway69123 6y agoI think your calculating market value wrong.
- triceratops 6y agoWhen selling a product, it's pretty standard to provide more value to the customer than the price you charge. If art degrees are already low value, increasing their price is stupid.
- throwaway69123 6y agoThe customer isnt paying so the anology doesnt hold. The tax payer is largely footing the bill for these degrees that provide little economic uplift.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It's actually idiotic and anti-market. It’s not anti-market for a subsidizer to cut subsidies for things that don't produce things the subsidizer wants as effectively as other alternatives, so the direction of both the fee effects and the funding changes is sensible. The relative size of the two changes (the subsidy changes being larger than the fee changes), which means that the university gets less for the job-ready degrees and more for the less-useful ones, however, is silly.
- triceratops 6y agoThe job-ready stuff makes no sense to me. People want jobs - that's why they go to college. And when they do they try to find a major that has maximum overlap between their strengths, interests and earning potential. You aren't going to make engineering any more attractive to someone by making it cheaper, if the salaries weren't already doing it.
- pb7 6y agoIf the only option are paying X for something that will easily pay it off and set you up for life, and paying 2X for something that won’t, it will make it more attractive. Or people will opt out of college entirely, which is also sometimes better than getting a useless expensive degree.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> People want jobs - that's why they go to college. Historically that wasn’t particularly true, and presently it's only sometimes true. > And when they do they try to find a major that has maximum overlap between their strengths, interests and earning potential. I suspect that the share of applicants that does anything approaching an analysis that would support that conclusion is closer to 0% than 100%. You seem to be both making assumptions about motivation and rationality (in the economic sense) that aren't well grounded. > You aren't going to make engineering any more attractive to someone by making it cheaper, if the salaries weren't already doing it. At the level where the subsidy makes the difference between being able to afford the program at all and not, you certainly will. But even at higher income levels it'll make a difference, especially for people who aren't malign decisions on long-run economic analysis but more on “college is expected” and “it all costs the same, and X sounds fun”.
- triceratops 6y ago> At the level where the subsidy makes the difference between being able to afford the program at all and not, you certainly will. But if it's a money-making degree, you can get a loan for it and pay it off after getting a job. Affordability is unlikely to be a concern in that case.
- pb7 6y agoThat’s not going to work. The goal is to disincentivize students from getting degrees in low paying fields with few job options. People opting for cheap arts degrees would flood the already limited market, further driving down wages.
- triceratops 6y agoPeople opt for "cheap arts degrees" because they're interested in them, not for their earning potential. If they wanted to make money, they'd go into law, engineering or medicine. Why not just let the low wages for arts degree holders work their magic in providing a disincentive?
- pb7 6y agoAustralian tax payers subsidize tuition costs. It’s not interesting to them to produce degrees that will not contribute to that same tax revenue for the next generation.
- rexreed 6y agoThat's not entirely true. People opt for these degrees because they believe they need a diploma to succeed. The specifics of the diploma is not as substantial as the diploma itself. They're paying for the paper and not the educational value. If they truly wanted to pursue higher education in liberal arts, then they would continue on the path to academia. But for most, their education stops once they get the piece of paper that is the diploma.
- fiblye 6y agoSupply and demand. Demand for certain fields is high, so governments are willing to put more money into them because they're more likely to pay off in the future. Meanwhile, certain art majors are in very low demand and supply is high, so governments aren't willing to pay. Not saying what they're doing is right. Just saying that from a purely economic perspective, it makes sense. I don't think university should be purely economically driven, though.
- triceratops 6y ago> governments are willing to put more money into them because they're more likely to pay off in the future... certain art majors are in very low demand and supply is high, so governments aren't willing to pay. Pay off for those respective industries, and the people in them. So why should taxpayers subsidize something that would be profitable and paid-for anyway? Government should be subsidizing things that the market won't pay for precisely because there're no money in it.
- fiblye 6y agoThe government has incentives to invest in things that boost its own economy. A government that pays for 10 engineers will likely get a bigger return that one that pays for 10 art history majors. Paying for something that has little industrial use and doesn't boost GDP numbers would actually be idiotic and anti-market.
- triceratops 6y agoIf a degree has industrial use, why doesn't industry pay for it? Why are taxpayers pulling out their checkbook?
- fiblye 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subsidy Governments often pump money into things seen as having long term benefits for a country. Examples: investing in agricultural independence, roads, phone networks. An entirely free market would still have these. Government investment gives it an initial push to develop faster. Australia decided they have some fields they should prioritize for national development. The idea of people working in one industry or one company for life is long gone, so expecting a company to subsidize someone's education just isn't happening unless they're already in the company. Furthermore, an entirely free market approach to art majors would probably have even fewer art majors. If governments didn't subsidize degrees or offer loans or funding or anything of the sort, nobody but the elite would be studying art history at the academic level at all. So the government either remains completely neutral and funds things equally, it funds nothing at all, or it funds according to national needs. Some countries choose #1 or #2. Australia chose #3.