3 ms·
You are arguing against a straw man. The author did not claim that inter-country wealth/income is a product of IQ rather than economic systems. In fact, he has
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
You are arguing against a straw man.
The author did not claim that inter-country wealth/income is a product of IQ rather than economic systems. In fact, he has already disputed this claim - in another post, he shows that Swedish Americans are considerably richer than Swedes, and attributes this to the economic system:
http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-one-picture.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-o...
He is merely disputing a claim made by David Brooks and Malcolm Gladwell of "no correlation between accumulating large wealth and high IQ."
- notahacker 16y agoI was arguing against the author's quite explicit and unequivocal statement the left is wrong about the market allocating income mainly based on chance, connections or "power". In fact, earnings are strongly linked with intelligence. Unless he wishes to extend his argument to demonstrate how Swedish Americans have significantly higher IQs than native Swedes, I'm going to have to insist that "the left" is right and he is wrong about the role of chance, connections and power versus innate intelligence when it comes to distribution of incomes on a macro scale. Economic systems don't exist in isolation.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoAgain: he is referring to intra-country variation, you are referring to inter-country variation. From his post: "Denying the link between productivity and earnings is very important for the modern left, as their entire source of outrage is based on the view that the capitalist system "exploits" the poor. More likely, because of the modern welfare state and because of the growing importance of human capital, more resources are transferred from the productive rich to the poor than vice-versa." If he were making international comparisons, these two sentences would make absolutely no sense. The modern welfare state does not redistributed from richer Americans to poorer Swedish. He is clearly describing only intra-country variation.
- notahacker 16y ago(Old debate, but still) I would argue that claiming to refute left wing "exploitation" arguments by focusing purely on intra-country variation, as if the US economy lived in a bubble isolated from the rest of the world, is attacking a straw man. The "modern left" is far more concerned that American capitalists are "exploiting" highly productive cheap foreign labour, to the detriment of US-based jobs in many sectors. After all It's the people that don't have jobs that are the major welfare beneficiaries and don't have any capital to invest in China. Regardless of whether this is ultimately a good thing (even those without access to capital to invest in multinational ventures get cheaper consumer goods...), the fact that on a macro scale cost of labour is related at least as much to geography than productivity is pretty fundamental to left wing arguments that the rich are having it too easy and many US citizens without access to capital wouldn't be able to afford to eat without welfare and some protectionism.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago...the fact that on a macro scale cost of labour is related at least as much to geography than productivity is pretty fundamental to left wing arguments that the rich are having it too easy and many US citizens without access to capital wouldn't be able to afford to eat without welfare and some protectionism. If only Tino (the author of the blog post) thought of that. Then he might have written this: "There is so little demand in the labor market for unskilled people that the poor in industrialized countries increasingly don't even work full time. The fact that the rich don't exploit the [same country] poor doesn't mean the rich shouldn't help the poor. But it's one thing to claim you are rich because you are stealing from poor people, and another to believe you have an obligation to help all members of society due to randomly having being granted more valued skills." Oh wait, he did think of it and wrote exactly that (minus the words in brackets, which I added). The point he is making is that if you want to argue for intra-country welfare, the argument that the rich owe the (same country) poor because they exploit them is fallacious. And implicitly, I believe he is assuming "same western country, particularly the US", since all his data is from the US. As you note, it's the people without jobs who need welfare and it's hard to exploit someone who isn't working (only 15% of poor adults work, or even seek work). So clearly, the US poor are not being exploited.
- wazoox 16y agoHe failed to demonstrate how higher income is unequivocally better, though. Compared to a more homogenous society, for instance.