4 ms·
How many other factors than beheading can affect a persons risk of dying from being beheaded?
by kickling 6y ago
How many other factors than beheading can affect a persons risk of dying from being beheaded?
- thaumasiotes 6y agoA huge number. People die without being beheaded all the time.
- youdonthavekids 6y agoYou did not understand the question.
- mgraczyk 6y agoThe relevant statistic is not how many people die, it's how many people die in a short time window. The probability of a particular person dying in a 5 minute interval after being beheaded is much larger than the probability of a particular person dying in an interval after they were not beheaded.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoThat just shows that beheadings are targeted at people who were already about to die.
- mgraczyk 6y agoYeah I think it really reveals a breakdown in our ability to quantitively model the intuitive notion of "causality". A targeted public health intervention that prevented beheadings just at the time of beheading would clearly break the link in the causal change. This result is insensitive to any imaginable confounders. However, the executioner would find another strategy, say a gunshot or noose, which did not appear anywhere in our dataset. Really makes you question the validity of observational studies. At least when acts of government are concerned.
- nsl73 6y agoYes the answer is more than 1, but because the mechanism of action is so well understood and the temporal association so strong the answer is less than 10.