3 ms·
Even if we deploy batteries, wind and solar in an amount needed to mitigate a climate change crisis, the amount of mining and industrial activity that would tak
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
Even if we deploy batteries, wind and solar in an amount needed to mitigate a climate change crisis, the amount of mining and industrial activity that would take would greatly poison our planet in other ways. In terms of "other stuff you need to do" per MW none of these come close to touching fission. Fusion, being much cleaner than fission would be a holy grail of clean cheap energy.
I hope it only takes 50yr to figure out and scale up fusion, that would be great.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoWhat part of a wind turbine 'greatly poisons iur planet"? Its an electric generator on a mast. How is it more poisonos than any other industrial object or consumer device?
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>What part of a wind turbine 'greatly poisons iur planet"? The batteries they're going to be paired with unless some other storage tech becomes better or windmills become so cheap that we can use less storage or inefficient storage. The windmills themselves are mostly fine since they're just fiberglass, metals and concrete. Mining for the things that go into batteries is just as destructive as the mining done for coal. It just happens in Asia so nobody cares. If you destroy the suitability of land for habitation or certain crops (likely by affecting the watershed) then you create many of the same problems climate change would/will cause. If you make mining less destructive to the environment batteries become more expensive hampering renewable adoption. It's a catch 22. Don't get me wrong, it's better than fossil fuels and better than anything involving a solar panel (which has all the mining related dirtiness on the energy production side as well as the storage side) but compared to the bang for your buck you get by knocking atoms around it's a hell of a lot of industrial activity.
- Reason077 6y ago> "Mining for the things that go into batteries is just as destructive as the mining done for coal." Most of what goes in to batteries can be recycled. You can't recycle coal.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThey dont have to be paired with batteries, there are several cheaper industrial storage systems like comoressed air and pumoed storage, or concrete blocks moved vertically