3 ms·
Most critical paragraph IMO: > When I share news clippings of so-called ‘female soldiers’ or ‘female sailors’, students are quick to say that these people were
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
Most critical paragraph IMO:
> When I share news clippings of so-called ‘female soldiers’ or ‘female sailors’, students are quick to say that these people were not ‘really’ trans. When I ask why they think this, students offer two reasons: the soldiers and sailors were motivated by some other need (patriotism and/or poverty) or they didn’t live as men for very long. It is my job, of course, to help students unpack and contextualise these newspaper accounts [...] I think one of the most powerful insights is the absence, for the most part, of a concept of ‘gender identity’ in the 19th century. Distinguishing ‘trans’ from ‘not-trans’ is futile and, in many ways, the least interesting route to approach this rich and varied material. What can we – in our ‘cisgender’ and ‘transgender’ 21st century – learn from an era when this distinction was murkier?
I sometimes wonder if, in some ways, the emphasis we place on gender today is actually putting people in more of a box. Identifying as "non-binary" is one way out of that—but why should it even need a special designation? People—everyone—should dress and act as they wish.
- TehCorwiz 6y agoSpecial designations evolved as they always do. Initially by those who sought to insult. There is a wide collection of vulgar terms for what we now refer to as trans, lgbt, etc. if you do not choose a name, someone will choose one for you.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut imagine a world in which a boy who wants to wear a dress one day can just go ahead and do that, without it saying something critical about their identity. It shouldn't matter whether the child feels innately feminine, or isn't sure yet, or just wants to try on a damn dress because why the hell not? It seems to me that transgender labels preclude such a society, where you are whoever you're presenting yourself as at that moment.
- Kye 6y agoWe can prefer a world world without labels, but we have to live in this one. Ripping off the label someone else applied to make room for self-definition is a way to deal with reality.
- TehCorwiz 6y agoYou don't need to be LGBT to wear a dress. I (Male) wore calf-length skirts for a good chunk of my 20s and didn't need a label. There are ways of feeling out who you are and what you're about without labels, privately or within your peer group. But when you want to live publicly that way. When you want your boss, store clerk, principal to know you as that then someone, anyone, will find a word for you unless you have one for yourself. Especially if your public transition is a rarity in the community you live in.
- elil17 6y agoI don’t think the label “trans” precludes that society. Most trans people I know recognize that there’s a distinction between acting feminine and being a woman. It’s people with conservative views about gender who use trans people to justify traditional gender roles when relatively few trans people even want to fit into those roles.
- watwut 6y agoIn more a box compared to what? Because if you check the past, the female husband was at risk of getting criminal charges.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- elil17 6y agoA lot of non-binary people I know have brought this issue up. Non-binary has become its own box in certain areas of society. Non-binary means being stereotypically androgynous, and androgyny means having no breasts, no beard, no make-up, and “boy” clothes. In certain social circles, well intentioned people will assume that anyone who looks like a flat chested woman dressed in men’s clothes is non-binary. Meanwhile, they’ll assume that anyone who looks like a man wearing women’s clothes is a trans woman. In reality, the “man in a dress” could be non-binary and the flat chested woman could be a trans woman. I don’t really have a proposed solution to this problem, I just think it’s interesting to note how gender roles can shift so much over time but in other ways remain so rigid.
- Izkata 6y agoThe response to the students is really weird. We already have a separate term that separates the two: Crossdressing. Transgender specifically refers to when some sort of body-image dysphoria is involved. The students have it right, crossdressing for patriotism or poverty isn't transgender in and of itself.