- your initial comments are only ad-hominem - i don't think kelvin's statement represents her views - Being against a new collider does not mean one takes the

- your initial comments are only ad-hominem - i don't think kelvin's statement represents her views - Being against a new collider does not mean one takes the position of Kelvin, or is anti-science. She doesn't argue against investment in novel science. Her argument is that a larger collider is the wrong kind of investment to make, based on what we've already observed at the LHC