5 ms·
One would expect child labor shops to not have the same moral reservations that parents and teachers have.
by Apocryphon 6y ago
One would expect child labor shops to not have the same moral reservations that parents and teachers have.
- WalterBright 6y agoAbusing people doesn't result in very effective workers. It's another reason why free markets outproduce coercive economic systems.
- Apocryphon 6y agoThat's because abuse and coercion leads to workers pushing back. So what are labor unions, then, but a natural by-product of a free market capitalist system?
- WalterBright 6y agoThere is nothing anti free market about unions.
- rvense 6y agoThis is an incredible argument. Abuse and coercion (and poor working conditions in general, and long working hours, lack of holidays and sick leave and all the other things that progressive politics and labour unions have given us) are extremely common part of the workplace outside of western society - say in clothing sweatshops, on deep sea fishing ships, or many other places. This will possibly get better if and when the workers in these places get better opportunities for bargaining, but of course there will be push-back from the factory-owning classes. Similarly, child labour is still very common and as far as I'm told in some places even on the rise, so there must be more to the story of its disappearance from the west than "children make bad workers".
- nickpp 6y agoYou’ll notice that those abusive places outside the "western society" seldom have functioning free markets. That is what made those societies successful anyway: freedom which brought innovation which brought prosperity. Not the fact that they were "western".
- rvense 6y agoBut this isn't proof at all that economic freedom is what leads to improved conditions for workers. It's hardly the Chinese government that's forcing the hand of the poor sweatshop owners, just like it wasn't Queen Victoria who made 19th century steel mills what they were. It was factors like the labour movement and progressive governments that gradually forced capitalism to temper itself and allow the working classes to live better lives, and there is absolutely nothing to suggest that this will not have to replay itself outside of the west.
- nickpp 6y agoNo. What improves the lives of employees is competition between employers for said employees. For that you need enough employers and thus - startups. Which require economic freedom.
- rvense 6y agoAre you seriously saying that the advancement in worker's conditions in the late 19th and throughout the 20th century were due only to employers being in competition with one another, and not due to legislative demands and union pressure? That the difference between conditions in, say, France and America are because French employers are just nicer people or have faced stiffer competition?
- WalterBright 6y agoI've been both employer and employee. When employees don't like their job, they quit and move on. If that wasn't true, every employee would be at minimum wage, and Google wouldn't offer free lunches.
- rvense 6y agoI'm not really talking about 20-something software developers in Silicon Valley. There are things that keep people in jobs they don't like.