5 ms·
Almost everyone, deep into trad Republican groups, agree that the Floyd killing was a sickening murder, a symptom of a broken system, and Something Needs To Be
by BurningFrog 6y ago
Almost everyone, deep into trad Republican groups, agree that the Floyd killing was a sickening murder, a symptom of a broken system, and Something Needs To Be Done.
My take is that nothing gets done because Congress is incapable of doing things. At all. There is nothing special about doing nothing on police brutality. It's just one more thing on the pile of unaddressed things.
It's been this way for a long time now, and that is why Presidents now try to rule by executive orders.
- cafard 6y agoThere are two layers of elected government between Congress and the Minneapolis police, and several layers of administration between the elected representatives and the police on the street. Ever hard-head in Congress could have a conversion experience this week from attending John Lewis's funeral, and somewhere next year some guy with a gun or knee could repeat the Floyd killing.
- jjcon 6y ago> My take is that nothing gets done because Congress is incapable of doing things. At all. I mean yes but also... Plenty of us just got and unprecedented $1200-2400 from Congress just a month or two ago... they clearly can act when motivated.
- coffeemaniac 6y ago> Almost everyone, deep into trad Republican groups, agree that the Floyd killing was a sickening murder, a symptom of a broken system, and Something Needs To Be Done. I need you to know that this is not the case. A not insignificant portion of the right does not feel anything wrong was done in this case, and would prefer for police to "crack down." Some will openly discuss that they need to publicly concede that there is A Problem in order to suggest ineffectual solutions to it which will satisfy politicians and pacify mass movements. The rest of your comment is very correct, but it should be mentioned that bad actors exist and not every American's ideal version of America is completely rid of police murders.
- ufmace 6y ago> I need you to know that this is not the case. What is your source or qualification for saying this? I know of several conservative groups that did infact hold or participate in protests against George Floyd's death in the days after. Pretty much everyone in them agrees, even now, that while the case is not quite as clear-cut as some would have you think, it was still wrong to kneel on his neck for 10 minutes after he was already under control. The right-libertarian circles have been banging on against the militarization of the police and their unaccountability for decades now. Check out Radley Balko in particular, and the books he's written and the articles for reason.com. That's what conservatives saw this as. Things did kind of turn over the weeks after. This was when the left's narrative that it was a racism problem took hold, the rhetoric escalated into "Defund the Police", and protests into some areas turned into riots and large-scale property destruction. This caused the right to de-emphasize those concerns and put more emphasis on the defense of the police. Naturally, the Left is incentivized to dig up the most outrageously extreme version of those arguments and try to portray the entire Right as thinking like that. I do not know you or your ideology, but I suspect your source is Left-wing articles that seek to portray the Right in this way. If so, you ought to be aware that it's never a path to truth to view any group only through the lens of their enemies.
- BurningFrog 6y agoAgreed on Radley Balko. He is the best writer on police brutality, AFAIK. https://www.washingtonpost.com/people/radley-balko/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/people/radley-balko/ https://twitter.com/radleybalko https://twitter.com/radleybalko
- ufmace 6y agoIndeed, IMO he's covered many sides of this issue very much in need of attention. Sadly, per the point of the article, it doesn't offend enough people or fit neatly enough into a right-wing or left-wing outrage machine, so it doesn't get a huge amount of attention.
- pjc50 6y ago
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Almost everyone, deep into trad Republican groups A large portion of the right were happy to spread justifications for Floyd's murder and defamation of Floyd's character all over social media. If you'd like evidence, search r/The_Donald archives, r/Conservative or the thousands of conservative groups on Facebook.
- BurningFrog 6y agoThere are loud internet agitators/troll who do this. It's important to not take that as some kind of opinion poll. "One Click One Vote" is a terrible slogan. Not that I have a poll to offer, though some have surely been done. I base what I say on most conservatives I'm aware of saying so. I can't think of any "name" conservative who has said the opposite.
- refurb 6y ago"A large portion of the right...all over social media." I'm not sure social media reflect "a large portion" of any political spectrum.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI am basing my observations off of the conservatives that I know personally, but offered evidence in the form of public social media used by millions of people because a common retort to this observation is skepticism or the claim that people like this don't exist.
- druddha 6y agoThe use of EOs isn't new, and we're not even in the ballpark of high-water marks there: https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/statistics/data/executive-orders https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/statistics/data/executive-or....
- darkerside 6y agoI look at it as building software on top of an extremely complex system. It's just not going to move as fast as anybody likes it to, and often the best course of action after considering a new feature will be to leave it alone because it's not business critical and worth the risk.