3 ms·
> Probably because they aren't saving enough to be able to weather bad times, because a serious medical issue may ruin them, because no matter how much you save
by nl 6y ago
> Probably because they aren't saving enough to be able to weather bad times, because a serious medical issue may ruin them, because no matter how much you save, housing, college, and medical costs will grow in tandem, and because despite official unemployment being low, most employers aren't willing to compromise on worker-hostile policies.
Noting that this was in 1997, this is basically the same point Greenspan was making - he is speculating they felt insecure and so weren't willing to do things like go on strike. It seems a reasonable theory although it's difficult to test if it is correct or not.
Either way, it most certainly doesn't indicate that Greenspan saw this insecurity of workers as a goal.
- vkou 6y agoSo, to make a different criticism from Chomsky, I will note that regardless of whether insecurity of workers is an end goal, an explicit goal of the fed is to maintain 'low' but non-zero unemployment. This, at least, is well-documented. The left, naturally, points to that as an example of how the government is actively taking steps to depress the labour market (during good economic conditions). Would you find that criticism to be more on-the-nose than Chomsky's claim?
- shuckles 6y agoThe Fed’s goal is in fact to promote maximum employment, and a non-zero unemployment rate is necessary for that: https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/money_12848.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/money_12848.htm Related to the discussion on insecurity, it is a good outcome to have an economy where people quit jobs and spent months on a careful job search. 0% unemployment means that nobody does that.
- vkou 6y agoThe link fails to argue for why it is necessary for that. Instead, it just says that's the fed's mission. > it is a good outcome to have an economy It's a good outcome for employers, not employees. If I can quit my job in the morning and get one I'm happy with before lunch, that's good for me - but it also means that employers are desperate for labour. A sober, careful, multi-month job search is not a good thing for most people. They can't afford it, because they have bills to pay this month, not next year.
- nl 6y ago> It's a good outcome for employers, not employees. If I can quit my job in the morning and get one I'm happy with before lunch, that's good for me - but it also means that employers are desperate for labour. > A sober, careful, multi-month job search is not a good thing for most people. They can't afford it, because they have bills to pay this month, not next year. Your first case (quit and get a job before lunch) is bad for the economy because it means production is constrained by the availability of labor. That is bad for employees even in the short term because it forced employers to find alternatives. I agree a multi-month job search is a bad thing, and I absolutely agree that avoiding that should be a goal of economic policy. Low, non-zero unemployment addresses this well: if there are many people spending multiple months on job searches then unemployment rises.
- vkou 6y agoProduction being constrained by the availability of labour doesn't mean one whit to me. I don't benefit from increased national production. The overwhelming majority of my expenses go towards things that aren't constrained by national production. Employers always want to find alternatives to paying people for their labour. That's also not my problem. It's an incredibly weird argument to be making. Employers need a thumb placed on their side of the scale, because otherwise... The country will produce fewer goods then it otherwise would? And because otherwise, they'll seek to reduce their costs, by employing fewer people? They are always motivated to do that anyways, and they are in a much worse position to do it than if they could trivially fire and replace their workforce, and if they are slower at accumulating profits.
- nl 6y ago> an explicit goal of the fed is to maintain 'low' but non-zero unemployment. This, at least, is well-documented. > The left, naturally, points to that as an example of how the government is actively taking steps to depress the labour market (during good economic conditions). I'm left leaning and I'd say anyone who thinks zero unemployment should be a goal is naive and uniformed. Zero unemployment means for example forced employment of unmotivated employees, and zero market dislocation from geographic mobility. https://theconversation.com/why-the-unemployment-rate-will-never-get-to-zero-percent-but-it-could-still-go-a-lot-lower-103665 https://theconversation.com/why-the-unemployment-rate-will-n... is a good discussion of this.
- vkou 6y agoThere are many unemployment rates. Generally speaking, the unemployment rate that we are talking about in this thread is 'What percentage of people who are actively looking for jobs can't find jobs?' Getting it to zero does not require any forced employment, or any restraints on geographic mobility, or babushkas with home scales weighing you for five kopeks at the entrance to the Leningradski railway terminal.
- shuckles 6y agoNo that’s not the unemployment rate we’re talking about, because you are using it to critique Fed policy, and that’s not the Fed’s definition of unemployment rate.