3 ms·
I see this quite differently. Yes returns on capital have blown up, while working and middle class incomes have stalled. This is a real issue and is driving a l
by simonh 6y ago
I see this quite differently. Yes returns on capital have blown up, while working and middle class incomes have stalled. This is a real issue and is driving a lot of problems across the developed world.
I just think the factors behind this are somewhat different from the usual class war rhetoric - on both sides. I think the first effect is the introduction of hundreds of millions of workers in developing countries. China obviously, but also South Korea, Taiwan, also India particularly in financial and IT services. This has created a lot of downward pressure on labour prices in the developed world.
I think another effect is the property market sweeping up huge swathes of individual wealth and income. By and large there's a limited stock of desirable property. We all need a place to live, and when we have families and children we want the best home we can afford for them and us. That means increasing proportions of our wages have been spent in a bidding war against each other over the available housing. Certainly here in the UK this is a huge problem. Massive state subsidies to help new home owners get into property has just exacerbated the problem, hugely inflating the price of low and mid level housing particularly. Preferential tax treatment of property investments (in the UK anyway) also encouraged huge numbers of people to invest in property and become landlords.
I'm no economist so maybe I'm overestimating these shifts because I've seen and felt the effect of these factors personally, but I'm convinced they're having a considerable impact. On developing world labour I'm not sure much can be done about that, these people deserve jobs as much as anyone. I think things will even out though, I go to China regularly and wage growth over there has been staggering. As for property prices, it's about time we took a close look at the tax treatment of whats essential rental income and also inheritances. I think there's a shift needed favouring income from labour over capital. Don't get me wrong, I'm a thoroughgoing capitalist, but there's an imbalance there that needs redressing without resorting to class war eat the rich crap.
- WalterBright 6y agoYou're right that governmental attempts to artificially make things more affordable ends up blowing up the costs. For example in the US, education and health care. Prices for things with no government subsidy or interference have dropped to essentially zero - like software.
- mindcrime 6y agoYou're right that governmental attempts to artificially make things more affordable ends up blowing up the costs. For example in the US, education and health care. The "Law of Unintended Consequences". This constantly trips up well-intentionend people who support government interference in markets. Their goals are noble, but quite often the outcome is the exact opposite of what was intended.
- zozbot234 6y ago> Yes returns on capital have blown up This hasn't happened. Rising incomes in the upper-middle class and above since the 1980s are largely driven by labor income in highly skill-biased sectors. (You'd think that the HN crowd would be rather familiar with this whole dynamic, but apparently not.)
- simonh 6y agoOK, interesting. I'll have to look into that.