3 ms·
Let's turn the discussion from race to institutional geriatrics. Lawrence Mead (the author) is 77 years old (few years too old to be considered as a boomer)
by nabla9 6y ago
Let's turn the discussion from race to institutional geriatrics.
Lawrence Mead (the author) is 77 years old (few years too old to be considered as a boomer)
Jonathan Imber (Editor-in-Chief ‘Society’ Journal) seems to be 71. (His CV says "London School of Economics and Political Science, 1972-73" and he was the Class of 1949 Professor in Ethics).
Just by looking at the references in his article it's clear that Mead is not kept up with the field since late 90s. It's blast from the past.
As populations age, people in scientific institutions and publications age as well. Unlike many other professions, academics can stay active and hang into important positions semi-retired until their 80's. There is nothing wrong with that in individual level, but if they keep occupying an overly large portion of important positions in science it becomes a bottleneck that sustains old outdated viewpoints.
It seems that Lawrence Mead's work was criticized and debated in the 80s and 90s and it was laid to rest. Instead of asking for a retraction, scholars should look deeply into the relevance of the journals, universities, and how up to date people in their positions are. It's perfectly understandable that organizations filled with people who started their careers in the 70s don't have BIPOC among them.
- thinkingemote 6y agoYesterday on hacker news there was a post about ageism in tech. I suppose ageists have a point and we on HN are in the wrong /s
- nabla9 6y agoThis is not about ageism. Old academics are valuable but having people in high positions who have not contributed meaningfully for decades is not acceptable. People should step down when they can't keep up. Repeating arguments from 20-30 years ago without anything new is disgrace.