5 ms·
> I simply don’t read the same vast conspiracy in the memo that you imply. Even if it was a conspiracy it isn't obvious it is a conspiracy against the common g
by roenxi 6y ago
> I simply don’t read the same vast conspiracy in the memo that you imply.
Even if it was a conspiracy it isn't obvious it is a conspiracy against the common good. The American economic system has been a powerful force for good in the world - America is a hugely popular migration destination because of their superior economics and the alternatives at the time of the letter were places like the Soviet Union, Maoist China or Europe re-emerging from the rubble of their failures to maintain order and prosperity.
They weren't talking about "Communists" who were advocating for "like, life sucks for the poor, man" or modern "fascists" who want less immigration. The communists had just finished killing millions of people and their signature accomplishment were some of the greatest mass famines in history. Everyone knew someone who died fighting actual militant fascists. A rational person would have been very interested in protecting the American economic system as one of the few shining lights of progress in 1971.
- shuckles 6y agoYour second paragraph makes an important point: when reading texts from the 70s it's important to remember that they're using "Communists" and "Leftists" to describe groups who, in the public imagination at the time, were extremely destructive and pervasive. Big cities had hundreds of bombings, weird leftist cult leaders would commit unequivocal crimes and get sympathetic, top-tier legal representation. These were not the relatively subdued Tumblr leftists or Scandinavian socialists of today, even after accounting for COINTELPRO distortions of the historical record. A particularly striking example is the case of Lincoln Hospital in NYC which was taken over by a leftist group named the Young Lords that received a million bucks a year from the famously bankrupt city government to run a putative methadone clinic and Marxist education intensive. The details are a bit of an aside, but long story short the clinic had poor outcomes for patients, doctors dying of heroin overdoses, staff absentee rates in the 70%s, and about 4x more in spending per patient than city run hospitals. Yet it still kept getting funding renewed until 1978 through a variety of lobbying schemes. Some contemporary publications write of this medical failure fondly: https://filtermag.org/how-the-young-lords-took-lincoln-hospital-and-left-a-health-activism-legacy/ https://filtermag.org/how-the-young-lords-took-lincoln-hospi....
- throwanem 6y agoYou should source your claims, especially when they're heterodox. Calling the People's Program clinic a failure is pretty heterodox, and you've already admitted you have an axe to grind.
- shuckles 6y agoI have no axe to grind. Where did I admit that? Is it simply by saying that I've lived through regimes where worker power was itself a (if not _the_) problem? For what it's worth, I am generally on the left end of the spectrum; certainly economically if not socially. You’re right - I should have offered a source. You can reference the extensive reporting here: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/307365/days-of-rage-by-bryan-burrough/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/307365/days-of-rage...
- throwanem 6y agoCalling Days of Rage "reporting" is hardly without controversy [1]. [1] https://monthlyreview.org/commentary/fictionalizing-radical-activism-of-the-1960s-a-review-by-dan-berger-of-brian-burroughs-days-of-rage/ https://monthlyreview.org/commentary/fictionalizing-radical-...
- shuckles 6y agoYour source generally disputes the framing of the book but not the facts. Do you have evidence that the facts I cited about Lincoln Hospital’s expenses, lack of accounting controls, and death and drug abuse rates among providers are incorrect?
- throwanem 6y agoOh, it disputes a lot of the facts, too. So do at least some of the people who gave interviews to Burroughs, interviews whose content the interviewees later described his having misquoted or in places outright fabricated. Do you have any reasonably sturdy evidence that the claims you made are correct? Until you can prove them, you have cited no facts, but only made claims. Those claims are yours to support. Asking me to prove a negative doesn't really accomplish anything in that regard.
- tsimionescu 6y agoYou're missing the fact that, by the 1970s, the rate of US-caused murders and famines (abroad, to be fair) had far outpaced anything the USSR was doing [0]. Ruthless capitalist imperialism has been at least as destructive as any other imperialist style in history, if not more so. The American economic system has always lived on the shoulders of the American Empire - with almost free access to exploit resources within and outside the US with little regard for human life, especially the lives of non-citizens (slaves, foreigners). Combined with public research being funneled into private hands, usually under the guise of military research (see the entire IT industry in the 1960s-70s, and bio-engineering today); and with vast subsidies, either direct or as government guarantees of financial products; the capitalist system owes much of its success to the vast power of the American state, and has never been successfully replicated in significantly weaker countries (though it has been tried time and time again, usually under American guidance).
- solidasparagus 6y agoUtterly ridiculous. Capitalist imperialism is certainly not without major issues, but comparing the harms to other imperial styles like colonialism is insane. Show me where US imperialism did anything comparable to the Holodomor or the atrocities of the Congo Free State.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- claudeganon 6y agoVietnam, Indonesia, lots of Latin America in the 1980s? The US was also an actual colonialist power in the Philippines.
- square_usual 6y agoFor a start: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contras#Atrocities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contras#Atrocities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indonesian_mass_killings_of_1965%E2%80%9366#Foreign_involvement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indonesian_mass_killings_of_19...