4 ms·
That's the silly, confusing view of accounting. Here is the smart view: 1. The sum of all accounts is zero: that's the fundamental equation. Nothing about ass
by kazinator 6y ago
That's the silly, confusing view of accounting.
Here is the smart view:
1. The sum of all accounts is zero: that's the fundamental equation. Nothing about assets, liabilities or equity.
2. A transaction updates at least two accounts, by applying deltas to them. The sum of the deltas is a transaction zero. Because of that (1) continues to hold.
3. Accounts which represent outside interests in the business run negative: these include loans and owner's equity. For instance, if the business somehow makes $1000 out of thin air, its cash account goes up by $1000. At the same time, because the owner has interest in the business, the equity goes down by $1000. Equity is like a loan that the business owes to the owner. Or, if the business gets a loan for $1000, the cash goes up; but the loan account goes down by $1000. Other accounts are what the business has, and run positive, like expenses, cash and assets. E.g. if a routine $50 expense is covered, cash goes down by $50, expenses goes up by $50.
4. Expensese are periodically reconciled (e.g. end of year): they cancel out equity. If there is -$1500 equity, and $500 expenses: poof: expenses are blasted to zero, and equity goes to $-1000. (Of course, expenses are also, separately of this, used for claiming tax deductions and whatnot.)
That's it; no confusing debit/credit nonsense, with an increase in such and such account being a debit, but an increase in another kind being a credit. That system is deliberately twisted so that people of typical intelligence need to rely on expensive accountants.
- racecar789 6y ago#1 and 2 are generally correct. Personally, I would remove the quote "nothing about assets, liabilities or equity". Accounting is "all about" those accounts. #3 couple edits: Change "the equity goes down by $1000" to "either equity or liabilities will increase by $1000". Equity will either remain the same or increase when a business obtains $1000 out of thin air. Change "the loan account goes down by $1000" to "the loan account goes UP by $1000". Obtaining a loan will increase cash/increase liability accounts. #4 is correct.
- kazinator 6y agoThat is wrong; the equity and liability accounts run negative in this view, because they represent external interests in the business. When equity increases, the equity account representation of it decreases; i.e. decrements toward negative infinity. > Equity will either remain the same or increase when a business obtains $1000 out of thin air. By "out of thin air" I meant that the business doesn't owe the money other than to its owners as equity. Like say the business won that in a lottery or something. > Obtaining a loan will increase cash/increase liability accounts You don't get the system obviously; you're thinking in the broken credit/debit system.
- kazinator 6y agoThough in accounting you have to be clear about what you have versus what you owe, and transactions must target the correct accounts in order to make sense, there is no need to befuddle the fundamental equation with those details. It is much clearer mathematically to have the fundamental equation be "all accounts always add to zero". That's it; no mention of their "type". Likewise, the increments/decrements in a transaction just have to add to zero. This is the same as conservation laws in physics; e.g. integral over a closed path over a conservative field. Or the Kirchhoff voltage law (sum of voltages around an electric circuit is zero). Debit/credit accounting is like designing a circuit in which for some silly reason we decided to mix conventional current and electron current! Oh, this is a liability resistor, so we use electron current, but this is an asset capacitor, so we use conventional current. The circuit law then doesn't add to zero, unless you remember which elements need to have their sign flipped, and you end up with strange rules like equity volages equal asset voltages minus liability voltages. Can you imagine doing such a thing when designing a device with hundreds of parts? Yet, big ledgers can likewise have hundreds of accounts. Then a corporation needs a small army of accountants to keep a simple thing straight. It's not just the adding to zero that is crystal clear, but the polarities of the accounts. When I see a negative balance account in the ledger, I have a good idea that it's an equity/liability account just from the balance alone. Minus means owing, plus means having: very clear.
- kgwgk 6y agoIf the only thing required to untwist the system is to switch the sign of everything on the liabilities side maybe it wasn’t so twisted after all. At least you have the good taste of keeping assets positive, unlike other people. :-)
- kazinator 6y agoAh, but the simple matter of fiddling with the sign has ramifications. You end up with people having to cram mnemonics into their heads like DEAD CLIC, and PEARL. On top of that, there are awkward limitations like a transaction having to work with exactly two accounts, one of which is debited and one of which is credited. The actual numeric deltas applied to the two accounts by the debit/credit can be any of the four combinations: UP/UP, DOWN/DOWN, UP/DOWN, DOWN/UP. Under the sum-to-zero system, it's very simple. Negative-running accounts is what the system owes to the outside, including to its owners. Positive accounts are what it holds. It doesn't own anything: all of what it holds is either owed to its owners, or else to other creditors, so the sum is zero. A transaction can update two or more accounts. The only rule is that all the deltas in the transaction add to zero. That's as far as keeping balance is concerned: of course, the transaction has to reflect reality and accounting principles. For instance, if $1000 is injected into the business somehow (the company wins a lottery draw), that could be mistakenly applied as "+1000 cash, -1000 bank loan" which validates, due to summing to zero. But it looks like the company made a $1000 draft against the bank loan, which doesn't reflect what happened. The correct transaction is "+1000 cash, -1000 equity": the company is $1000 richer and so the owners have a greater interest: it "owes" more to the owners. (It's sort of as if the owners actually got the money, and loaned it to the business). The debit/credit system's rule that a transaction must have a credit and debit of equal size also do not prevent bad transaction semantics: transaction from using the wrong asset or liability/equity account. It's just a gratuitous complication which provides exactly the same sanity check as summing to zero. In my accounting system for self-employment, I have transactions that update four or five accounts. In double-entry, that would have to be done via an awkward series of binary debit/credit pairs. Moreover, I also have some "virtual" accounts: pairs of accounts that maintain precisely opposite balances that sum to zero. These accounts provide figures useful for reporting. For instance, suppose that transactions for receiving income are broken down: income doesn't go into a single lumped account, but some of it into "cash", some of it into "income tax withholding", and some into a third account like "health fund". But, for the sake of periodic income reporting, we need the whole lump together. For that, we can instantiate a virtual account pair "income" and "income-neg". In the same transaction, "income" receives the total, and "income-neg" the additive inverse of that to keep the ledger balanced. We can query the "income" account to see the lumped income, and not have to ferret that out of the income transactions.