3 ms·
> >accountants don’t like negative numbers. > That’s the first I hear of that It might be more accurate to say that Western accounting evolved before the conc
by skissane 6y ago
> >accountants don’t like negative numbers.
> That’s the first I hear of that
It might be more accurate to say that Western accounting evolved before the concept of negative numbers became widely accepted in the Western world. Negative numbers were invented (or "discovered", depending on your preferences in the philosophy of mathematics) in China, and from there spread to India, and from India to the Islamic world by the Middle Ages. But when Western mathematicians learnt about them from Arab/Islamic mathematics, there was a lot of philosophical pushback – at first, Westerners didn't think the idea was valid. The idea was rather alien to the Western philosophical tradition originating in Plato and Aristotle. It was only really in the 19th century that Western mathematicians overcame all their philosophical objections and embraced them wholeheartedly. And then it took even longer for the concept to spread from academic mathematics into other disciplines and general education. By then, a lot of the Western tradition of accounting and bookkeeping had already formed without any reliance on the concept of negative numbers. (The concept of "credit" and "debit" serves a somewhat similar function, but is not quite the same concept.)
And accountants do use negative numbers. But, maybe if modern Western accounting had developed in a culture that looked on negative numbers more positively (excuse the pun), they might use them much more than they do?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> And accountants do use negative numbers. But, maybe if modern Western accounting had developed in a culture that looked on negative numbers more positively (excuse the pun), they might use them much more than they do? The division of accounts into credit- and debit-normal with a strong anti-negative-entry bias (to the point of contra sub-accounts for recurrent activities that go in the opposite direction of the parent account’s normal) seems to me like it provides an important QC feature, especially when books are kept or reviewed manually. It's a lot easier to see “this is not the kind of thing that belongs in this account” than “that is not the right sign for that activity”. And the resulting categorizations are useful in their own right, and it's important to remember that accounting is not just about adding numbers, but about categorizing the associated activities.
- navaati 6y agoGee, you're the first in the whole thread to have actual arguments instead of "B-B-But, you're wrong, I can tell because school told me !", thank you for that (and making me reconsider my position) !