3 ms·
It isn't an ill-informed author, Yanis Varoufakis is a very respected and competent economist. Of course! You could replace Bitcoin with any other fixed supply
by sudosysgen 6y ago
It isn't an ill-informed author, Yanis Varoufakis is a very respected and competent economist.
Of course! You could replace Bitcoin with any other fixed supply currency. This is literally the point of the article! He is arguing that Bitcoin cannot work for the common man, because it has all the issues of fixed-supply currencies that lead to fiat currency. Transitioning to Bitcoin would be akin to restoring the Bretton Woods system, and would be disastrous for everyone.
He is indeed addressing a feature and property of Bitcoin. That feature is fixed supply. That is what matters to an economist, because it has huge impacts. Varoufakis, in this essay, doesn't talk about the tech, because not only has he already done so, but because it is irrelevant to the analysis that he, as an economist, makes about the consequences of a switch to Bitcoin.
- joosters 6y agoA 'fixed supply' is not key to his points. Point 1 is, more specifically, that you would not be able to get agreement to adjust properties of the currency (remember, bitcoin is only 'fixed' in that there's a number in the code: with enough support, all the numbers can be changed). But he goes on to say that the problem is that the rich & powerful won't have incentives to adjust the money supply, something that could be argued about any money that already exists right now. Point 2 is just: there will be inequality, the rich stay rich, the poor stay poor. Yes, true, unless you do some huge form of wealth redistribution, you won't change this. But note that this again is not related to the new currency. Jeff Bezos will still remain rich no matter what features your new currency has, because he already is rich. So, I don't see how these points are related to bitcoin or in fact any currency.
- chrisco255 6y agoWhy would restoring Bretton Woods be disastrous? The late 40s through the late 60s were among the biggest economic boom years in world history and perhaps the greatest expansion of wealth and quality of living in human history.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe late 40s through the late 60s were amazing economic booms because of a small event called World War 2. It was removed because it gave very little flexibility in monetary policy, and gravely prevented deficit spending. This led to failure to control the business cycle, as well as inflation in general, which would have been disastrous. If we restored Bretton Woods, 2008 would have been a complete disaster, and the current recession would be orders of magnitude worse and would last much longer. As for why control over inflation and deficit spending is helpful in recession, read Krugman, or Keynes if you like the classics.
- chrisco255 6y agoThat's not strictly true. The suburbs were rolled out, interstate highway travel became widespread, commercial air travel took off, computing was just beginning, television started to proliferate, retail expanded, air conditioning became widespread...there were numerous technological expansions and improvements in quality of life. Sound money ensured that money was invested in things that actually produced productivity improvements. We coasted on the residual returns of investments from earlier eras, but productive investment, I would argue, has declined since those earlier decades. ROIs on loaned money have declined in the zero interest rate era.
- kerkeslager 6y agoThe 40s through the late 60s were also the era of the Holocaust, the Indonesian Genocide, and the Serbian Genocide. Did Bretton Woods cause those too? Or can we agree that maybe a lot of things that happened during the 40s through 60s weren't caused by Bretton Woods?
- chrisco255 6y agoI said late 40s. Obviously there is a strong connection between monetary policy and economic expansion and a weak connection between monetary policy and genocide.