6 ms·
> We laughed that guy out of the room, thankfully. If the customer can be made happy and the company can make money by just making an increase to a version num
by paulcole 6y ago
> We laughed that guy out of the room, thankfully.
If the customer can be made happy and the company can make money by just making an increase to a version number with no additional changes, why not just do it?
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoBecause the customer already paid for those features and you're accepting that you'll dick them over for a few pennies.
- cyberpunk 6y agoBecasue selling something that they already own to someone as a new feature is unethical at best and illegal at worst? Don't you think the client would be happier with a refund and an explination?
- GavinMcG 6y agoBecause it's morally wrong to charge someone for a product they already have, and then to cover up what you've done. It's likely also criminal, as fraud is illegal, but even if not the deceit should be something that makes your conscience bristle.
- simonbarker87 6y agoMany products with embedded systems ship with the same firmware regardless if it’s the basic/mid/pro model where features are enabled/disabled with a flag set in the EEPROM. So to charge a customer $XX more the company just has to flip a bit at production time. Is that ethically ok do you think? Not sure I have an opinion either way so just curios, but it’s not a million miles from this scenario above .
- Jasper_ 6y agoIt's certainly not the same. In one case, the client had already paid for the feature but weren't aware, and a salesperson told them they needed to upgrade to unlock it (a lie). In the latter case, they simply didn't pay for the feature. Is it ethically wrong to ship chicken bits like that? You can make arguments either way (e.g. a device might not have been QA'd or tested for the disabled features, and the feature itself might be faulty, e.g. that's extra support labor they didn't pay for). But that's a different question to whether the salesperson should have sold them a feature they already had access to.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoThose features cost money to develop, but if someone is paying you for a feature and isn't using it, it's probably unethical to charge them.
- throwaheyy 6y agoIt’s totally fine. They’re not paying for the bits burned into the EEPROM, they’re paying for the effort it took to develop the capabilities.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoIt's potentially fraud
- paloaltokid 6y agoDid you actually read what the person was asking them to do? It could be illegal in the worst case.
- paulcole 6y agoYes, I did. In the best case it's a happy customer and more money for the company. I'm a glass-half-full guy.
- diob 6y agoYou'll make way more money in the long run if you own up to mistakes like this. It builds trust in your company, so that when they think about renewing their contract they remember you have integrity and aren't trying to rip them off. Instead, you believe in your product and are actually trying to sell it on its merits. It also becomes a funny story they tell their friends / others in the industry, which could lead to further business. There are no downsides to owning up (I'd even claim the upsides above), but there are some possibly gigantic downsides to not owning up.
- fossuser 6y agoThis is a reasonable consequentialist argument, but I think you could also argue that it's unethical and wrong to lie/mislead someone this way even if the consequences weren't potentially worse for you in the long run - even if by lying you might come out ahead.
- Nursie 6y agoAs others have said, it's effectively fraud at that point. The customer has already paid for that feature. Best case we rip them off and take their money for nothing, which is scummy. Worst case they figure it out later and sue. Either way it's the wrong thing to do.
- xmprt 6y agoThey should get a refund if they already paid for the feature. If you want to make money off of the situation then say you'll send a support technician or someone to look over their configuration and set it up to do what they want. That's the only legitimate and fair thing to do.