4 ms·
> At no other time in human history has one nation been as powerful and influential as America was, and to a certain extent continues to be. The US is influent
by Barrin92 6y ago
> At no other time in human history has one nation been as powerful and influential as America was, and to a certain extent continues to be.
The US is influential in a broad way but not in any particular deep way. Even Russia still has significantly more ability to penetrate the culture of countries where it is present.
If you visit a city like Astana this becomes blatantly obvious, the way the Russian language and politics influences daily life is present everywhere. In the Middle-East that is evident as well as Russia has re-established historical ties.
Whenever the US has gone somewhere militarily the way to build influence was basically with guns or coffers full of money, but it could never compete with the sort of influence historical empires or cultures can built that have deep religious, linguistic or ethnic ties, the US is in a very real sense isolated and fundamentally disconnected from history.
In the same sense exactly like the British Empire was, and we can see where the UK is now and it didn't even take 100 years. Bruno Macaes recently wrote a great piece about the comeback of the 'civilisation-state'[1], and here the US cannot compete.
[1]https://www.noemamag.com/the-attack-of-the-civilization-state/ https://www.noemamag.com/the-attack-of-the-civilization-stat...
- michaelt 6y ago> The US is influential in a broad way but not in any particular deep way. Depends whom you want to credit/blame for things like Hollywood, x86, the internet, wikipedia, google, facebook, jeans and tee-shirts and sneakers, apple, microsoft, smartphones, laissez-faire capitalism, private car ownership, crossover suvs, climate-change scepticism, the post-British-empire popularity of the english language... Perhaps some people are so immersed in American culture they can't see the forest for the trees, but American culture has been hugely influential over the past century.
- Barrin92 6y ago>Depends whom you want to credit/blame for things like no it doesn't, which is the point. Free market capitalism or common law or the internet is not culture, it's a sort of operating system and infrastructure to build stuff with, which can be adopted or discarded as a civilisation sees fit. China now has capitalism, is China now liberal? What are a hundred years? China and India are thousands of years old. Britney Spears and Steve Jobs and Disneyland are exciting for a few decades. Are they exciting for three thousand years? No, and that's something that the US has painfully experienced over the last few decades. It's sold its operating system to other societies the same way Microsoft sells copies of Windows, but it hasn't touched their culture.
- michaelt 6y ago> Free market capitalism or common law or the internet is not culture, In the current age social media can replace local news sources; smartphone cameras can produce a mass of video evidence of authority figures abusing their power; messaging apps can allow protesters to coordinate with their conversations unreadable by the government; foreign corporations' automated censorship copyright, fact-checking and truth-in-advertising decisions arguably have more power over what citizens see and what apps they can run than local laws; and a important chunk of your white-collar worker citizens have to learn a foreign tongue to access the tools of their trades. If you think these are "not culture" your definition of culture is very different to mine.